When a Judge Gets the Law Wrong: Why Judicial Error Is Not Automatically Misconduct

The Supreme Court held that a judgeโ€™s erroneous or inconsistent order is not misconduct absent gross ignorance, bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, or corruption. Judges may commit reversible error without being administratively punished, so long as the mistake is not a blatant disregard of basic law and is not attended by bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, corruption, […]

When Court Delay Becomes Misconduct: Why Judges and Clerks Cannot Hide Undecided Cases

Judges and clerks may be sanctioned when cases remain undecided beyond the deadline and official reports conceal the true court docket status. Litigants are entitled not only to a fair decision, but to a timely and honestly monitored one. When a judge allows cases to remain undecided beyond the constitutional period and then files service […]

When an Ejectment Case Drags for Years: Judges Can Be Fined for Delaying Summary Proceedings

Judges handling ejectment cases must enforce summary procedure, avoid needless postponements, and decide on time or face administrative liability. Property litigants in ejectment cases are entitled to speed, not endless resets. When a case is covered by summary procedure, the judge must control the proceedings, reject improvident delay, and decide within the period fixed by […]

When Court Delay Comes From Bad Records, Judges and Clerks Can Be Personally Sanctioned

Court delay from poor records management can lead to sanctions against judges and clerks, even after retirement, when litigants suffer needless delay. Litigants have a right not only to a judge who decides cases, but to a court that keeps track of them. When case files are incomplete, hearing settings are missed, summonses are delayed, […]

Delayed Court Rulings Can Trigger Discipline Even After Retirement

The Court disciplined a retired judge and branch clerk for delayed case action, confirming that docket delay can trigger liability even after retirement. Judges and court clerks can be held administratively liable when unresolved cases and motions remain unattended beyond mandatory periods, even if the judge later retires or the matters are eventually disposed of. […]

When Bail Is Discretionary, Judges Must Still Hold the Hearing That Protects Both Sides

Judges must hold a real bail hearing in capital cases before granting bail; skipping the evidentiary process can result in discipline. A person charged with a capital offense does not automatically lose the right to seek bail, but the judge cannot grant bail on instinct, sympathy, or shortcut procedure. When bail is discretionary, the court […]

Judges Cannot Make Litigants Wait While Cases Drift Toward Settlement

A judge was fined for delaying a forcible entry decision despite summary procedure deadlines, confirming that settlement efforts do not excuse court inaction. Judges who hold back decisions because they hope the parties will settle do so at their own administrative peril. Once a case is deemed submitted for resolution, the court must act within […]

Judges Who Delay Simple Cases Can Be Fined Even When the Decision Is Eventually Issued

Court fined a judge for delayed judgment in a summary criminal case, while holding that failure to object waived the private prosecutor issue. Litigants in small criminal cases are entitled to more than a correct final judgment; they are entitled to a timely one. In Enriquez v. Judge Vallarta, the Court disciplined a trial judge […]