Judges Cannot Jail Parties for Indirect Contempt Without Due Process

Indirect contempt requires a written charge and hearing before arrest. The Court fined a retired judge and voided an improper arrest order. Indirect contempt cannot be punished by arrest first and hearing later. When a judge orders a person jailed for allegedly disobeying a writ, the court must first require a written charge and give […]

When a Judge Misreads a Basic Probation Rule, Liberty Is at Stake

A judge was disciplined for mishandling probation and bond withdrawal after appeal, showing how basic criminal procedure rules protect liberty. Trial judges may be disciplined when they apply a basic criminal procedure rule in a way that unlawfully exposes an accused to arrest, detention, or loss of liberty. The ruling in Creer v. Judge Fabillar […]

Final Judgments Stay Final: When Judges Can Be Disciplined for Ignoring Res Judicata

A judge was disciplined for disregarding res judicata and deciding a later property case contrary to a final judgment involving the same parties and land. A judge who reopens issues already settled by a final judgment may face administrative discipline, even if the losing party believes the later ruling was merely an error in judgment. […]

When a Judge Performs a Civil Wedding Outside His Territory, the Marriage Record Still Matters

A judge was fined for solemnizing a rushed civil wedding outside his jurisdiction and mishandling marriage records, underscoring Family Code safeguards. A civil wedding performed by a judge outside his assigned territorial jurisdiction may expose the judge to discipline, even when the couple’s immediate concern is simply to get married quickly. The ruling teaches a […]

A Pending Ownership Case Does Not Stop Ejectment Execution

A pending ownership or title case does not automatically stop execution of an ejectment judgment; the judge was reprimanded for delaying enforcement. A party who wins an ejectment case should not lose the practical benefit of that victory merely because the losing occupant files or invokes a separate ownership case. In this ruling, the Supreme […]

When a Judge Delays Your Case, Mandamus May Expose Administrative Liability

A judge may be reprimanded for delaying summary ejectment cases when inaction forces a party to seek mandamus and the excuse for delay is flimsy. Litigants are not helpless when a trial judge allows a supposedly summary case to stall: if a judge refuses or delays action despite a clear procedural duty, the delay may […]

Judicial Impropriety Doctrine: Private Deals After Litigation

Judges may avoid Article 1491 liability after final judgment, but private deals tied to former cases can still warrant discipline. The Judicial Impropriety Doctrine teaches that a judge may escape civil or criminal liability for a private transaction, yet still be disciplined when the transaction creates an appearance that courts are being used for personal […]

When a Government Salary Withholding Can Satisfy a Disciplinary Penalty

A judge’s six months of unpaid service was treated as full satisfaction of a disciplinary fine, avoiding duplicate punishment and court disruption. A judge who already lost six months of salary while continuing to work may have that financial loss treated as full satisfaction of a later disciplinary penalty, where further suspension would punish the […]