Court Employees Cannot Meddle in Pending Criminal Casesโ€”Even Without Proof of Bribery

Court employees may be disciplined for intervening in pending cases even without proof of bribery, while judges must use restraint in official complaints. Court employees who personally approach a judge about a pending criminal case risk administrative liability even when bribery is not fully proven. The practical rule from Judge Fineza v. Aruelo is straightforward: […]

Case Raffles Must Be Real: Why Judges Cannot Handpick Cases Even for Speed

Judges cannot bypass mandatory case raffles for convenience. Directly assigning cases to one branch undermines impartiality and may lead to discipline. Courts cannot sacrifice the neutrality of case raffles in the name of convenience, speed, or even a seemingly practical concern for accused persons seeking provisional liberty. When a judge directly assigns cases to his […]

Judges Are Not Disciplined on Suspicion Alone: Proof Still Matters in Court Misconduct Complaints

The Court dismissed a judicial misconduct complaint, holding that suspected conflict and docket delay do not prove liability without evidence, not suspicion alone. Administrative complaints against judges require evidence, not suspicion. A judge is not automatically liable for judicial misconduct merely because a spouse-lawyer has cases in the same court, or because the courtโ€™s docket […]

Judges Who Use Media Platforms for Personal Attacks Can Be Removed from Office

Judges may be removed for public attacks and media conduct that erode impartiality, even outside the courtroom, when conduct shows judicial unfitness. Judges do not leave the obligations of judicial office at the courtroom door. When a judge uses a newspaper column, publication, or public platform to insult public officials, pursue personal quarrels, encourage litigation, […]

Judicial Bias Complaints Need Proof, Not Suspicion

Bias complaints against judges require proof. Lastimoso v. Judge Lambo cleared a judge but warned courts to avoid remarks that cast doubt on impartiality. Litigants who believe a judge is biased may file an administrative complaint, but suspicion alone is not enough: the complainant must be willing to prove the charge, and a judge may […]