Judges Cannot Let One Side Write the Decision: What Heck v. Judge Santos Means for Litigants

A judge may not let one party’s lawyer draft the court decision and adopt it verbatim; the proper remedy for legal error remains appeal, not discipline. A court decision must be the judge’s own work, not the handiwork of one party’s lawyer. For taxpayers, business owners, and litigants in civil or tax-related disputes, the practical […]

When a Judge Attacks the Investigator: Why Temperate Language Matters in Court Discipline

A judge may defend himself, but unsupported attacks on an investigator violate judicial restraint; the Court reduced the fine but upheld discipline. Judges do not lose their right to defend themselves, but they do lose the privilege of doing so with reckless accusations, hostile language, or insinuations unsupported by the record. In De la Cruz […]

When a Judge Appears Biased: Why Impartiality Must Be Seen, Not Just Claimed

Judges may be disciplined when their conduct creates an appearance of favoritism, but adverse rulings alone do not prove misconduct without bad faith. Litigants are entitled not only to a judge who is actually fair, but to a courtroom where fairness is visible from the record, the proceedings, and the judge’s conduct. When a judge’s […]

Municipal Judges Cannot Practice in Courts They Supervise

A municipal judge was censured for appearing as counsel in another municipal court, reinforcing that judicial neutrality must exist in fact and appearance. Judges who are allowed to practice law outside their own sala must still avoid appearances that can compromise public confidence in impartial justice. In Agdeppa v. Judge Javier, the Court treated a […]