Judges Must Explain Their Decisions: Why Bare Acquittals Can Still Lead to Discipline

Judges are presumed in good faith absent proof of bad faith, but decisions must state facts and law; unexplained judgments may trigger discipline. A judge may be spared from discipline for an allegedly wrong judgment when bad faith or gross incompetence is not proven, but the judge may still be admonished for issuing a decision […]

A Judge Cannot Force an Unrepresented Accused to Cross-Examine Witnesses

A judge was severely censured for forcing a non-lawyer accused to cross-examine witnesses and ordering reimbursement under threat of contempt. Courts may move cases forward, but speed cannot come at the expense of basic fairness: an accused person who is not a lawyer cannot be compelled to conduct his own cross-examination merely because his counsel […]

A Judgeโ€™s Mistake Is Not Misconduct Without Proof of Bad Faith

Judicial error alone is not misconduct. The Court dismissed a complaint against a judge but warned that officials must be circumspect in deciding cases. Litigants who lose a case cannot convert every unfavorable or even mistaken court decision into an administrative case against the judge. The doctrine is practical and important: judicial discipline requires more […]

Judicial Error Is Not Misconduct Without Proof of Bad Faith, Bias, or Corrupt Intent

Judicial error is not misconduct without proof of bias, bad faith, dishonesty, or intent to violate the law. The Court dismissed the complaint against the judge. A losing party cannot turn an unfavorable court ruling into an administrative case against a judge unless there is proof that the judge acted with bad faith, bias, ignorance, […]

Judicial Delay Complaints Need Proof of Bad Faith, Not Frustration With the Court

A judge is not administratively liable for delay, exhibit management, or encouraging family compromise absent proof of bad faith, coercion, or misconduct. A judge is not administratively liable for delay, strict courtroom management, or efforts to settle a family dispute unless the complainant proves misconduct, bad faith, coercion, or abuse of authority. For litigants, the […]

When Losing in Court Is Not Enough to Discipline a Judge

Adverse rulings do not prove judicial misconduct. PAFLU v. Tabigne requires clear evidence before a judge may be disciplined for alleged bias or delay. A party who believes a judge acted unfairly cannot secure judicial discipline merely by pointing to adverse orders, delay, or dissatisfaction with how a case was handled. The complainant must prove […]