When a Resignation Letter Defeats an Illegal Dismissal Claim

The Supreme Court ruled that signed resignation letters, settlement benefits, and quitclaims can defeat constructive dismissal claims absent concrete proof of coercion. Employees who sign resignation letters, accept separation benefits, and execute quitclaims may later lose an illegal dismissal case if they cannot prove that their resignation was forced. In Saudi Arabian Airlines v. Castells […]

When a Company Merger Does Not Erase Employee Tenure or Union Obligations

A merger preserves employee tenure, but absorbed workers may still be bound by a valid union shop clause and must receive due process before dismissal. Employees absorbed through a corporate merger keep their continuity of employment, but they may also become subject to an existing union shop clause if they enter the surviving company’s bargaining […]

Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine: Limits on Work Injury Claims

Employers owe work injury medical costs only while disability subsists and treatment can still restore capacity, not as lifetime medical coverage. The Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine limits an employer’s liability for work-related medical expenses once the employee’s compensable disability has already reached the point where treatment can no longer restore him to work or to […]

A Missed Service Copy Should Not Kill a Worker’s Labor Appeal

A worker’s NLRC appeal should not be dismissed for a non-prejudicial failure to serve a copy when substantial justice requires review on the merits. A labor appeal should not be dismissed on a purely technical defect when the worker timely filed the appeal, acted in good faith, and the missing copy to the employer did […]

Union Election Protests Must First Be Fought Inside the Union, Not Before Labor Officials

Union election disputes must generally pass through internal union remedies first; labor authorities cannot intervene absent a true intra-union conflict. Union members and officers cannot automatically bring every disputed union election to labor authorities. When the controversy is essentially about ballots, internal protest rules, and the union’s own election machinery, the first battleground is the […]

Work-Related Illness Claims Cannot Be Defeated by Silence: Why Employers Must Timely Controvert Compensation Claims

An employee’s illness during work may be presumed compensable when the employer fails to timely dispute the claim, allowing heirs to recover benefits. Employees and their heirs may still recover disability benefits when a work-related illness appears during employment and the employer fails to timely dispute the claim. The practical rule is simple but powerful: […]

Illness During Employment Can Be Enough to Trigger Compensation Benefits

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer proves it was neither caused nor aggravated by the worker’s job. Families of workers who become seriously ill while still employed are not required to prove medical causation from scratch when the law itself creates a presumption in their favor. Under the Workmen’s Compensation framework […]

When Work-Related Illness Is Presumed Compensable: A Teacher’s Victory Against a Late Government Appeal

A teacher’s disability award was restored after a late government appeal failed and work-related illness was presumed compensable absent contrary evidence. Employees who become ill after years of service may invoke a powerful presumption: when the illness arises during employment, the employer must prove by substantial evidence that the work neither caused nor aggravated the […]

When Illness Strikes at Work, Employers Must Overcome the Presumption of Compensability

The Court reinstated disability compensation after holding that illness during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer rebuts it with substantial evidence. Employees who become ill or disabled while still in government service do not begin from zero: under the old Workmen’s Compensation Act, the law presumed the illness compensable unless the employer produced substantial […]

When a Union Certification Fight Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide Bargaining Rights for Vessels No Longer Operated

A union certification challenge was dismissed as moot after the employer stopped operating the vessels involved and the union showed no active interest. A union certification dispute can disappear before the court reaches the merits when the employer no longer operates the workplace or vessels involved, the union shows no continuing interest, and no present […]