When Outsourcing Is Not Labor-Only Contracting: Supreme Court Clarifies the Equipment Rule for Service Contractors

Supreme Court clarifies when manual support work may be validly outsourced and why lack of equipment does not always prove labor-only contracting. Service contractors are not automatically labor-only contractors merely because their workers perform manual support tasks inside a clientโ€™s premises or because the contractor does not bring heavy equipment to the job site. Where […]

When Outsourcing Is Not Labor-Only Contracting: Why Substantial Capital Can Save a Service Contractor

The Supreme Court held that a capitalized contractor with real supervisory control may be a legitimate employer despite output monitoring by the principal. Companies that outsource support functions are not automatically treated as employers of deployed workers simply because those workers perform tasks inside the companyโ€™s plant or contribute to its operations. The key lesson […]

When Outsourced Workers Are Not Automatically Employees of the Client Company

The Supreme Court held that outsourced workers assigned inside a clientโ€™s premises are not automatically client employees absent proof of labor-only contracting. Workers assigned inside a clientโ€™s factory do not automatically become employees of that client. The controlling question is not where the work is done, but who hires, pays, disciplines, and actually controls the […]

When a Contractor Is Just a Corporate Mask: Employees May Sue the Principal Employer for Illegal Dismissal

A principal company may be treated as the real employer when a contractor is merely a labor-only conduit, but officers need proof of bad faith for personal liability. Employees assigned through a contractor may still claim illegal dismissal directly against the principal company when the contractor is undercapitalized, unregistered, dependent on the principal, and used […]

When a Quitclaim to a Labor-Only Contractor Can Also Release the Principal Employer

Valid quitclaims signed with a labor-only contractor may also release the principal employer because solidary liability allows payment by one debtor to extinguish the claim. Workers who accept separation pay and sign a valid quitclaim in favor of a labor-only contractor may also lose their claims against the principal employer, because payment by one solidary […]

When a Contractor Is Just a Labor Supplier, the Principal Employer Pays

Labor-only contracting can make the principal employer solidarily liable for unpaid wages and illegal dismissal when the contractor lacks real capital or independence. Workers assigned through a contractor are not always limited to suing the contractor that signed their papers. When the contractor lacks substantial capital, tools, equipment, or an independent workplace, and the workers […]

When a Business Closes Without Proving Serious Losses, Employees May Still Receive Separation Pay

Business closure alone does not defeat separation pay. Employers must prove serious losses, and active corporate officers may face personal liability. Employers who close a business cannot avoid separation pay simply by saying that operations have ended. When the closure is not supported by clear proof of serious business losses or financial reverses, employees may […]