Judges Cannot Gamble in Cockpits and Casinos Without Damaging Public Trust

Judges may be disciplined for public gambling-related conduct even if not illegal, because judicial office requires conduct that preserves trust in courts. Judges may be disciplined even for conduct outside the courtroom when their public behavior undermines confidence in the judiciary. A magistrate who openly appears in gambling venues, even if the games are licensed […]

Lawyers Facing Disbarment Are Entitled to a Real Hearing, Not Just Paper Review

Serious disbarment complaints require an IBP formal investigation; paper review alone cannot resolve factual disputes involving alleged forgery and misconduct. Disbarment complaints against lawyers cannot be dismissed through a paper-only review when the accusations are serious and factual issues remain unresolved. The practical rule is simple: before a lawyer is cleared or condemned in a […]

When a Lawyer Uses Cases as Revenge: The Rule Against Vindictive Litigation

A lawyer may be suspended for filing multiple complaints as retaliation, because vindictive litigation reflects unfitness to practice law. Lawyers may be disciplined not only for courtroom misconduct, but also for using the legal system itself as a weapon of harassment. The doctrine from the Saburnido ruling is simple but powerful: a lawyer who files […]

When a Lawyer Turns Settlement Talks Into a Litigation Weapon, Ethics Rules Can Step In

A lawyer was reprimanded for soliciting a reconsideration letter for settlement, then using it in court against the writer without fair candor. A lawyer who invites an opposing party to write a reconsideration letter as a possible path to settlement may commit professional misconduct if he later uses that same letter against the writer in […]

When Fee Collection by a Lawyer Becomes an Ethics Case—and When It Does Not

A disputed lawyer’s fee claim is not automatically malpractice. Disbarment requires clear, convincing proof of deceit, gross misconduct, or unethical conduct. A client who disagrees with a lawyer’s later fee claim does not automatically have a disbarment case. The controlling lesson is evidentiary: professional discipline requires clear, convincing, and satisfactory proof of deceit, malpractice, or […]

A Judge’s Silence Can Cost Him the Bench: Why Affidavits of Desistance Do Not Stop Judicial Discipline

The Supreme Court held that a judge may still be dismissed for gross misconduct despite a complainant’s affidavit of desistance or loss of interest. Judges and court personnel cannot make an administrative case disappear simply because the complainant later withdraws, signs an affidavit of desistance, or stops cooperating. When the alleged misconduct affects public trust […]

Court Clearances Are Not Favors: Why Public Officers May Be Punished for Helping Someone Evade Accountability

Public employees may be disciplined for issuing clearances as personal favors when accountabilities remain unresolved, even if done out of pity or courtesy. Public officers who issue clearances, certifications, or internal approvals cannot treat them as personal favors. When a government employee uses an official document to help another avoid accountability, even out of pity […]

A Missed Proof of Service Can Suspend a Lawyer and Derail an Appeal

Lawyers handling appeals, tax controversies, and other deadline-driven proceedings can face suspension when they neglect even a procedural requirement that prevents the opposing side or the government from performing its own duty in court. The lesson is direct: a missed filing step is not always a harmless technicality. When it reflects neglect of a client’s […]

A Retired Judge Can Still Be Disbarred for a Decision That Corrupts a Litigant’s Case

A retired judge was disbarred after the Court found he issued a property decision after retirement, proving legal ethics liability survives public office. A lawyer who leaves the bench does not leave behind accountability for acts committed while wearing the robe. When a former judge is later shown to have prepared or issued a decision […]