When a Lawyer Takes Your Money, Silence Can Become Legal Neglect

A lawyer who accepts a fee may be disciplined for neglect if he fails to act on the client’s case, though client non-cooperation can reduce the penalty. Clients who pay a lawyer to handle a case are entitled to more than passive acceptance of a fee: once the lawyer-client relationship arises, the lawyer must act […]

Lawyers Cannot Let Appeal Deadlines Expire Based on Their Own Case Strategy

A lawyer was suspended for letting an appeal deadline lapse based on his own view that appeal was futile, violating the client’s right to decide. A client’s right to appeal belongs to the client, not to the lawyer. When counsel allows the appeal period to lapse because he personally believes an appeal would be useless, […]

When a Lawyer Settles Without the Client’s Consent, Suspension Can Follow

A lawyer who settled a client’s case without consent and kept the proceeds was suspended for five years for deceit, malpractice, and gross misconduct. Clients are entitled to control the settlement of their own cases, and a lawyer who compromises a claim without authority, fixes the terms alone, and keeps the proceeds commits serious professional […]

When a Lawyer Loses a Case, Is It Malpractice? The Best-Efforts Rule in Lawyer Discipline

A lost case is not automatically lawyer negligence. The Court dismissed a disciplinary complaint absent proof of deceit, grave omission, or culpable neglect. A lost case does not automatically make a lawyer administratively liable. A client who seeks discipline against counsel must prove culpable negligence, bad faith, dishonest conduct, or grave omission—not merely that another […]

When a Lawyer Misses the Appeal Brief Deadline, the Client Is Not Automatically to Blame

A lawyer cannot let an appeal deadline lapse by blaming unpaid printing costs. Counsel must seek relief, inform the court, or protect the client’s case. A lawyer handling an appeal cannot excuse a missed brief deadline simply by saying the client failed to advance printing costs. If the lawyer remains counsel of record, the duty […]

A Lawyer’s Death Can End a Disbarment Case, But Not the Client’s Need for a Separate Remedy

Death of a lawyer can render a disciplinary case moot, reminding tax clients to preserve separate civil, tax, and estate remedies before deadlines lapse. A disciplinary complaint against a lawyer may be dismissed as moot when the lawyer dies before the Court can proceed, because disbarment and administrative discipline are personal sanctions directed at a […]

When a Missed Appeal Is Not Enough to Discipline a Lawyer

A missed appeal does not automatically prove lawyer misconduct. Discipline requires convincing evidence, especially where the client consented and appeal appeared futile. A client who loses a case cannot automatically convert that loss into a disciplinary case against counsel merely by saying that an appeal should have been filed. In lawyer discipline, the complainant must […]

Legal Malpractice Complaints Need Evidence, Not Fee Disputes Alone

The Court dismissed a malpractice complaint against a lawyer, holding that fee disputes and suspicion cannot justify discipline without credible evidence. Clients who feel disappointed by a lawyer’s work may file an administrative complaint, but disappointment, suspicion, or a later disagreement over fees is not enough to discipline a member of the Bar. The ruling […]