Tax Exemptions Do Not Automatically Cover VAT: What PLDT Teaches About Franchise Tax Refunds

PLDT clarifies that broad franchise tax exemptions do not automatically cover VAT or indirect taxes, but obsolete compensating and advance sales taxes may be refunded. Companies holding legislative franchises cannot assume that a broad tax exemption automatically wipes out VAT, import duties, or other indirect taxes. The controlling rule is narrower and more practical: unless […]

Franchise Tax Clauses Do Not Automatically Shield Telecom Property From Local Real Property Tax

Telecom franchise holders remain liable for real property tax when their franchise expressly taxes real estate, buildings, and machinery despite broad exemption language. Telecommunications companies cannot rely on broad franchise language alone to avoid local real property tax when the same franchise expressly makes their real estate, buildings, and machinery taxable. The RCPI ruling is […]

When Congress Changes a Tax Franchise, Tax Exemptions Can Disappear Overnight

Franchise tax exemptions may be withdrawn by Congress, but penalties may be removed when the taxpayer’s liability was genuinely uncertain and controversial. A company operating under a legislative franchise cannot assume that an old in-lieu-of-all-taxes clause will permanently shield it from income tax. When Congress validly amends the tax law and withdraws prior franchise exemptions, […]