Operative Fact Tax Reliance: When Invalid Tax Laws Still Matter

Invalid tax laws may still affect past conduct: good-faith taxpayers can avoid double payment, while agencies may retain prior tax effects. Operative fact tax reliance means that even an unconstitutional tax-related law may still produce consequences for transactions completed before it was struck down. For taxpayers, local governments, and businesses caught between competing authorities, the […]

When a Municipal License Tax Is Not an Illegal Sales Tax

The Supreme Court upheld Virac’s municipal license taxes, ruling that taxes measured by capital or purchases are not automatically illegal sales taxes. Local governments may impose graduated municipal license taxes on businesses based on capital investment or prior-year purchases, so long as the tax is imposed on the privilege of doing business and not directly […]