Actual Use Assessment Rule: Real Property Tax Limits in PH

Local governments cannot tax property by deed price alone; assessments must follow actual use, fair market value, and statutory appraisal rules. Local governments cannot automatically raise real property taxes just because land was sold at a higher price. Under the actual use assessment rule, real property must be valued through the appraisal methods authorized by […]

Franchise Tax Clauses Do Not Automatically Shield Telecom Property From Local Real Property Tax

Telecom franchise holders remain liable for real property tax when their franchise expressly taxes real estate, buildings, and machinery despite broad exemption language. Telecommunications companies cannot rely on broad franchise language alone to avoid local real property tax when the same franchise expressly makes their real estate, buildings, and machinery taxable. The RCPI ruling is […]

Local Franchise Taxes Still Apply Unless Congress Clearly Says Otherwise

Franchise holders remain liable for local taxes unless Congress grants a clear exemption. PLDT failed to recover Davao franchise taxes. Businesses operating under a legislative franchise cannot avoid local franchise taxes by relying on broad equality clauses, old exemptions, or favorable language in another company’s franchise. A tax exemption must be clear, express, and unmistakable; […]

Cement Tax Exemption Rule: Why Local Business Taxes Still Apply

Cement is a manufactured product, not a mineral product; mining tax exemptions do not bar local business taxes on cement sales and exports. The Cement Tax Exemption Rule warns manufacturers that a tax exemption for mining or mineral products does not automatically shield the downstream manufacture and export of cement from local business taxes. For […]

Cement Manufacturers Cannot Use Mining Tax Exemptions to Avoid Local Business Taxes

Cement manufacturers cannot rely on mining tax exemptions to avoid local business taxes on manufacturing and export activities, the Supreme Court held. A company that mines limestone cannot automatically treat its finished cement as a tax-exempt mineral product. When the business activity being taxed is the manufacture, sale, or export of cement, local governments may […]

PAGCOR Tax Supremacy: Why Local Fees Cannot Block Gaming Operations

Local governments cannot impose fees that obstruct PAGCOR’s national charter; constitutional attacks require a clear breach of the Constitution. The PAGCOR tax supremacy doctrine confirms that local governments cannot use license fees or local taxes to block a national government instrumentality from carrying out a gambling franchise authorized by Congress. For businesses operating in heavily […]

Metro Manila Rules Can Stand Even Without Separate City Referendums

Metro Manila may be treated as a special regulatory class, allowing unified governance when regional conditions justify different rules for businesses and taxpayers. Metro Manila-wide government action is not unconstitutional merely because it treats the metropolis differently from ordinary cities and municipalities. Where population density, shared services, traffic, utilities, public works, and regional administration create […]

When Government-Owned Property Cannot Be Forfeited for Local Real Property Taxes

Government-owned SSS property could not be forfeited for Bacolod realty taxes because public ownership, not proprietary use, controlled the exemption. Government-owned land and buildings are not automatically taxable merely because they are used by a public agency for operational or proprietary purposes. Where the law exempts property owned by the Republic from real property tax, […]