Employee Gratuity Pay Cannot Be Defeated by Corporate Technicalities After the Company Has Already Honored It

A company that ratifies employee gratuity pay through conduct and partial payment cannot later avoid liability through corporate technicalities. Employers that approve gratuity or retirement-style benefits for employees may remain bound even if they later claim defects in board notice, stockholder approval, or corporate authority, especially when the company has already begun paying the benefit […]

Automatic Return-to-Work Doctrine: Illegal Strikes in Labor Disputes

Assumption of jurisdiction automatically orders strikers back to work; defiance makes the strike illegal and may justify loss of employment status. The Automatic Return-to-Work Doctrine means that once the Secretary of Labor assumes jurisdiction over a labor dispute or certifies it for compulsory arbitration, striking workers must immediately return to work even if no separate […]

Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine: Limits on Work Injury Claims

Employers owe work injury medical costs only while disability subsists and treatment can still restore capacity, not as lifetime medical coverage. The Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine limits an employer’s liability for work-related medical expenses once the employee’s compensable disability has already reached the point where treatment can no longer restore him to work or to […]

When a Bank Becomes Liable for a Security Guard’s Work Injury Compensation

A bank hiring agency guards was liable as statutory employer for death benefits, but the security agency had to reimburse it under their contract. A business that hires agency personnel may still be treated as the worker’s statutory employer for workmen’s compensation, even if the service contract says the worker belongs exclusively to the agency. […]

Work-Related Illness Benefits Cannot Be Arbitrarily Reduced Without Evidence

A work-related illness award cannot be reduced without evidence. Jacoba restored full medical reimbursement for a public school teacher. Employees who prove that an illness is work-connected may recover compensable medical expenses, and an agency cannot simply reduce an award without a clear evidentiary basis. The practical rule from Jacoba is direct: once the compensability […]

No Employer-Employee Relationship, No Workmen’s Compensation Liability: Why Business Owners Are Not Automatically Personally Liable

A worker’s death may be compensable, but liability falls on the proven employer. The Court cleared an individual wrongly held personally liable. Workmen’s compensation liability follows the employer-employee relationship, not mere ownership labels, family assumptions, or a claimant’s decision to name a convenient individual respondent. For business owners, operators, and managers, the practical lesson is […]

Loss of Confidence Is Not a Shortcut to Fire Employees Without Proof

Employers cannot dismiss ordinary employees on vague loss-of-confidence grounds; Central Textile required proof, due process, and reinstatement when theft was unproven. An employer cannot convert an unproven accusation of theft into a lawful dismissal by calling it loss of confidence. For ordinary employees, security of tenure means that livelihood cannot be taken away on suspicion, […]

A Quitclaim Cannot Cut Off Workers Compensation Below What the Law Guarantees

A worker’s ₱800 quitclaim did not bar recovery of statutory compensation because settlements below the law and without required safeguards are void. An injured worker who signs a quitclaim for less than the compensation fixed by law is not automatically barred from claiming the balance. The controlling doctrine is simple but powerful: statutory workers compensation […]

When a Worker Dies on the Job, the Employer Must Rebut Compensability

Employee death during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer rebuts it. The Court restored death benefits for the worker’s family. Families of employees who die while still in the service of their employer are not required to prove every possible causal link between the death and the job before receiving compensation. Where death occurs […]