Mandatory DAR Formula Rule: Agrarian Just Compensation Must Follow Law

Courts must apply the DAR valuation formula in agrarian just compensation cases and cannot rely on unsupported judicial notice of land use. Landowners and government agencies in agrarian reform cases cannot rely on improvised valuations when the law has already supplied a binding valuation framework. Under the Mandatory DAR Formula Rule, courts still decide just […]

Revoked Agency Rule: When Property Managers Must Account

Revoked agents must surrender property control and account for income, but owners must prove rents, fruits, expenses, and deductions. The Revoked Agency Rule protects property owners who entrust land, leases, and harvest income to relatives, agents, or informal administrators: once the owner withdraws authority, the agent must stop managing the property, turn over administration, and […]

COA Pre-Audit Discretion: Why Taxpayers Cannot Compel Pre-Audit

COA may lift pre-audit of government transactions; taxpayers can sue over public funds, but courts cannot compel audit methods absent a clear duty. The COA Pre-Audit Discretion Doctrine means that taxpayers may question alleged misuse of public funds, but they cannot force the Commission on Audit to pre-audit every government transaction. For citizens, contractors, government […]

Revenue Target Due Process: BOC Attrition Upheld

Revenue target attrition is valid for BIR and BOC employees if standards, relevant factors, due process, and appeal rights are preserved. Revenue Target Due Process is the rule that government revenue officers may be subjected to performance-based removal laws, but only when Congress supplies clear standards, the agency considers relevant factors, and the employee retains […]

Incontrovertible Land Classification Rule in Philippine Land Registration

Land applicants must prove alienable status and possession since 1945; tax declarations and survey notes alone cannot secure title. The Incontrovertible Land Classification Rule means that a land registration applicant cannot win title over public land by relying on tax declarations, family history, or a survey plan notation alone. For property owners, heirs, developers, and […]

DAR Valuation Formula Rule: Just Compensation in CARP Land Cases

CARP just compensation must follow DAR valuation formulas based on actual land use, not speculative appraisals or potential future productivity. Landowners in agrarian reform cases cannot rely on speculative market appraisals or the land’s possible future use to increase compensation; the Mandatory DAR Valuation Formula Rule requires courts to apply the statutory factors and DAR […]

Prior Public Hearing Rule: When LGU Charges Become Void

LGU fees and market stall charges are void if imposed without a valid prior public hearing required by the Local Government Code. Local governments cannot impose market stall rentals, goodwill fees, or similar business charges by ordinance unless affected parties first receive the public hearing required by law. The Prior Public Hearing Rule means that […]

Third-Party Mortgage Priority: When Labor Execution Cannot Reach Assets

Prior registered mortgage rights can defeat later labor execution when assets belong to a third-party claimant, not the judgment debtor. The third-party mortgage priority doctrine protects a non-party mortgagee from having its mortgaged or foreclosed assets seized to satisfy another company’s labor judgment, even where the labor award itself is valid and final. For businesses, […]

Unregistered Land Sale Rule: Why Recording Protects Property Rights

Unregistered land sales bind only the parties unless recorded; an unrecorded deed cannot defeat third-party property claims. The Unregistered Land Sale Rule means that a buyer of unregistered land cannot rely on a private, unrecorded deed to defeat the rights of third persons. For property owners, heirs, and buyers in Philippine real estate disputes, the […]

Possession by Tolerance Rule: File Ejectment in the Proper Court

Possession by tolerance after demand is unlawful detainer, not RTC recovery; filing in the wrong court makes proceedings void. The Possession by Tolerance Rule can defeat a property owner’s case before the merits are even reached: when occupants originally stayed with the owner’s permission and are later asked to leave, the case may be unlawful […]