Unauthorized Law Practice: Why Legal Clinics Need Lawyers

Unauthorized law practice includes paid legal advice, document drafting, and legal ads by non-lawyers; the Court barred misleading legal clinic services. Unauthorized law practice is not limited to fake courtroom representation. The broader and more dangerous rule is that a person or business may cross the line into law practice when it gives paid legal […]

Flexible Tariff Power Doctrine: When Tariff Hikes Are Valid

Presidential tariff hikes may be valid even if revenue-raising when Congress delegates power within constitutional and statutory limits. The Flexible Tariff Power Doctrine confirms that tariff and customs duties may validly serve both revenue and regulatory purposes, so long as the President acts within authority delegated by Congress and within the constitutional limits on tariff […]

Public Plaza Nuisance Doctrine: When Demolition Must Wait

Public plaza structures may be nuisances, but demolition must wait when cadastral ownership and private rights remain unresolved. The Public Plaza Nuisance Doctrine protects municipalities that need to clear public land for public use, but it also warns government officials that demolition cannot be rushed when ownership is still unresolved. For property owners, local governments, […]

When a Voting Trust Removes Corporate Officers from Lawsuit Service Authority

A voting trust may remove former stockholders from director status, making summons served on them invalid if they no longer legally represent the corporation. A corporation cannot be dragged into court through summons served on former officers who no longer have legal authority to act for it. When a voting trust transfers legal title and […]

Oil Price Regulation Rule: When Courts Defer to ERB Decisions

Administrative agencies may grant provisional rate increases when due process is observed and substantial evidence supports the regulatory order. The oil price regulation rule means that courts will not easily overturn provisional fuel price increases when the agency has acted within its authority, observed administrative due process, and relied on substantial evidence. For businesses and […]

Arias Auditor Liability Rule: When Approval Is Not a Crime

A public officer’s approval or audit signature is not a crime unless evidence proves knowing participation, bad faith, or conspiracy. The Arias Auditor Liability Rule protects public officers from criminal conviction based solely on a signature, approval, or audit clearance, unless the evidence shows knowing participation, bad faith, or a duty to investigate the irregularity. […]

When Courtroom Discretion Becomes Discourtesy: Why Judges Must Give Lawyers and Parties Fair Consideration

Judges may reset hearings, but unexplained postponements handled discourteously can lead to discipline when counsel and parties are denied due consideration. Judges have broad authority to manage their calendars, reset hearings, and control courtroom proceedings, but that authority has a boundary: it must be exercised for a legitimate reason and with basic courtesy to the […]

When a Main Case Is Withdrawn, a Counterclaim May Fall With It

A counterclaim may fall when the main civil case is dismissed, and jurisdictional objections not raised below may be barred on appeal. A litigant who agrees to the dismissal of the main civil case cannot usually keep only the counterclaim alive as if it were an independent lawsuit. The practical lesson is simple but often […]

A Judgment Creditor Cannot Levy Property the Debtor Only Holds in Trust

A creditor cannot levy land the debtor holds only in trust; tax records, deeds, and third-party claims may prove beneficial ownership and stop execution sale. Winning a money judgment does not automatically give a creditor the right to sell every property appearing under the debtor’s name. When land is shown to be held in trust […]