Safeguard Tariff Review: CTA Jurisdiction in Import Disputes

Safeguard tariff disputes belong in the CTA; duties cannot be imposed without a positive Tariff Commission finding under Philippine law. The safeguard tariff review doctrine means that disputes over whether emergency import duties should be imposed belong before the Court of Tax Appeals, not through an ordinary certiorari case in the Court of Appeals. For […]

Infrastructure TRO Ban: Limits on Blocking Public Projects

Lower courts cannot stop national infrastructure bidding by TRO, but may still hear proper cases challenging illegal public project awards. Public infrastructure projects cannot be stopped by a temporary restraining order from a lower court merely because a taxpayer questions the bidding process. The Infrastructure TRO Ban Doctrine means that trial courts may still hear […]

Deed of Absolute Sale Doctrine: SC Clarifies Contract Validity and Performance

SC clarifies that deeds of absolute sale via Special Power of Attorney are enforceable only if conditions are ratified and incorporated, affecting property ownership rights. Property owners and buyers must now understand that a deed of absolute sale, even when executed through a Special Power of Attorney, is not automatically enforceable unless all conditions and […]

PCGG Jurisdiction Limit: Corporate Acts Need Proper Standing

Corporate acts of a former sequestered company do not become Sandiganbayan cases without PCGG recovery issues, public funds, or standing. The PCGG Jurisdiction Limit Doctrine protects corporate decision-making from being converted into a Sandiganbayan case merely because the corporation once had a sequestration history. For stockholders, taxpayers, and concerned citizens, the practical lesson is direct: […]

No Extrajudicial Closure: LGUs Cannot Shut Down Taxpayers at Will

LGUs may collect local taxes, but cannot close a business extrajudicially when lawful collection remedies and due process apply. The No Extrajudicial Closure Doctrine protects businesses from being shut down by a local government merely because of unpaid local taxes or permit fees. Even when a business is wrong about a claimed tax exemption, the […]

Charitable Property Tax Rule: When Nonprofits Still Pay RPT

Charitable owners get real property tax exemption only for areas actually, directly, and exclusively used for charitable purposes. Charitable institutions do not automatically escape real property tax on every square meter they own: under the charitable property tax rule, the exemption follows the actual, direct, and exclusive use of the property, not merely the nonprofit […]

Co-Ownership Sale Doctrine: Supreme Court Clarifies Property Rights and Laches

Supreme Court rules that co-owners cannot sell entire property without consent and emphasizes laches; clarifies pro-indiviso inheritance shares and prescription rules. Property owners and heirs now face stricter scrutiny when selling or claiming ownership of co-owned land, especially if decades have passed without asserting rights. The Supreme Court’s latest decision establishes that a co-owner cannot […]

Public Utility Over-Recovery: When Customers Must Be Refunded

Public utilities cannot pass income tax as operating expense or keep excess collections beyond the authorized return; customers may be refunded. The public utility over-recovery doctrine protects consumers from being charged rates that let a regulated utility earn more than the lawful return allowed by regulators. For businesses and households, the practical rule is direct: […]

When Court Staff Delay Transcripts or Meddle in Notices, Litigants Can Seek Administrative Discipline

Court personnel may be disciplined for meddling in court notices and delaying transcripts, protecting litigants from procedural irregularities and record delays. Litigants are not helpless when court personnel interfere with court notices, appear to favor one side, or delay the preparation of transcripts needed for a case. The doctrine from this ruling is straightforward: court […]

Court Records Cannot Be Quietly Repaired After Filing: What Litigants Should Know About Missing Forum Shopping Certifications

Court records cannot be quietly repaired after filing. A clerk was suspended after a missing forum shopping certification appeared later in the case records. Litigants cannot cure a missing certification against forum shopping by quietly inserting the document into the court records after a case has already been filed. When court records are altered to […]