Court Sheriffs Cannot Use Their Badge to Intimidate Citizens

Court sheriffs may be suspended for using their badge to intimidate citizens, reinforcing accountability for abusive conduct by court personnel. Court personnel may be disciplined even for misconduct committed outside the courtroom when they misuse the appearance of judicial authority. For litigants, taxpayers, business owners, and ordinary citizens who deal with sheriffs in enforcement proceedings, […]

Franchise Non-Delegation: PAGCOR Cannot Expand Jai-Alai Powers

PAGCOR cannot imply a jai-alai franchise from its casino charter; government franchises need clear legislative authority. Government franchises cannot be enlarged by implication when the activity is politically sensitive, commercially valuable, and reserved to legislative control. The Franchise Non-Delegation Doctrine matters because a corporation dealing with a government agency cannot rely on a broad or […]

When Contempt Becomes Personal: Why Judges Cannot Use Court Power to Punish Officials for Seeking Review

Judges may punish disobedience to court orders, but indirect contempt requires due process and restraint. Misuse of contempt power can trigger discipline. Court orders must be obeyed, but contempt power is not a judge’s private weapon. When a judge uses indirect contempt to punish government officials for pursuing available remedies, acting in apparent bad faith, […]

VFA Treaty-Concurrence Rule: When Foreign Pacts Bind the Philippines

Foreign military agreements bind the Philippines when Senate concurrence and treaty recognition requirements are met; policy objections alone fail. The VFA Treaty-Concurrence Rule confirms that a foreign military agreement may bind the Philippines when the Senate gives the constitutionally required concurrence and the other contracting State recognizes the agreement as a treaty. For citizens, advocacy […]

Judges Cannot Jail Parties for Indirect Contempt Without Due Process

Indirect contempt requires a written charge and hearing before arrest. The Court fined a retired judge and voided an improper arrest order. Indirect contempt cannot be punished by arrest first and hearing later. When a judge orders a person jailed for allegedly disobeying a writ, the court must first require a written charge and give […]

When Court Delay Becomes Dismissible Misconduct: Why Missing Transcripts Can Destroy a Case

Missing transcripts can violate litigants’ rights. The Court dismissed a stenographer for neglect, misconduct, and defiance of orders that delayed cases. Litigants are entitled to more than a judge who decides cases; they are entitled to a working court system where stenographic notes are transcribed, records move, and orders are obeyed. The doctrine of accountable […]

A Missed Proof of Service Can Suspend a Lawyer and Derail an Appeal

Lawyers handling appeals, tax controversies, and other deadline-driven proceedings can face suspension when they neglect even a procedural requirement that prevents the opposing side or the government from performing its own duty in court. The lesson is direct: a missed filing step is not always a harmless technicality. When it reflects neglect of a client’s […]

When a Sheriff Helps a Defendant Avoid Attachment, Court Discipline Can Follow

A sheriff may be suspended for conduct that helps a defendant defeat a writ of attachment, even without proof that he personally removed property. A court officer who assists, or even appears to assist, a litigant in defeating a valid writ of attachment may be disciplined even without proof that he personally carried the property […]