Arrastre Burden Rule: Cargo Loss Liability in Philippine Ports

Arrastre operators bear the burden to prove due care; a clean release receipt does not defeat cargo-loss claims when negligence and prior value notice are shown. The Arrastre Burden Rule means that a port cargo handler cannot avoid liability for missing cargo merely by pointing to a clean release receipt or suggesting that another party […]

When a Cargo Insurer Pays, the Carrier May Still Pay Next

Insurer may recover from a carrier after paying cargo damage claims; carriers must prove extraordinary diligence and cannot rely on mere denial of fault. A cargo insurer that pays a consignee for damaged goods can recover from the carrier without proving a separate written assignment, because subrogation arises by law upon payment. For shipping companies, […]

Foreign Insurers Can Sue Philippine Carriers for Cargo Damage After Paying the Claim

Foreign insurers may sue Philippine carriers after paying cargo losses when the claim arises from an isolated transaction and carrier negligence is proven. A foreign insurer that pays a marine cargo loss may sue the negligent Philippine carrier in its own name, even without a Philippine license, when the suit arises from an isolated insurance […]

Cargo Claims Fail When Delivery Records Show the Goods Left Custody Complete

Cargo damage claims fail without proof that the loss occurred in the defendantโ€™s custody, especially when delivery records show contents were complete. A cargo damage claimant cannot recover from an arrastre operator merely by showing that goods were later found leaking or damaged at the consigneeโ€™s warehouse. When the delivery documents show that the shipment […]