Environmental Writs Require Evidence, Not Alarm: What Mining Protesters Must Prove Before Stopping Operations

The Supreme Court dismissed a writ of kalikasan petition against Manicani mining operations for lack of concrete evidence of large-scale environmental harm. Communities opposing mining, reclamation, or other environmentally sensitive projects cannot obtain a writ of kalikasan by relying on broad fears of ecological harm alone; they must file the case with concrete evidence showing […]

Mining Permits Cannot Be Revived by the Wrong Appeal: Supreme Court Clarifies When DENR Orders May Be Challenged in Court

The Supreme Court held that DENRโ€™s implementation of a final FTAA revocation was administrative, not quasi-judicial, defeating a Rule 43 appeal. Companies dealing with mineral agreements and government permits cannot assume that every adverse DENR action may be appealed directly to the Court of Appeals. When the DENR merely implements a final administrative ruling or […]

Foreign Control Can Disqualify a Mining Company Despite Filipino-Looking Ownership

The Court allowed grandfathering where corporate layering cast doubt on Filipino ownership, disqualifying mining firms effectively controlled by foreign interests. Filipino ownership on paper is not enough when a corporationโ€™s real control and economic benefit appear to rest with foreign interests. In mining and other nationalized industries, companies that use layered shareholdings, joint ventures, or […]