Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Stockholders Skip Appraisal Rights Allegations

Stockholders’ derivative suit over a corporate mortgage was dismissed for failing to plead appraisal rights and non-harassment requirements. Stockholders who sue in the corporation’s name cannot treat a derivative suit as a shortcut around corporate remedies. When the challenged corporate act involves the sale, mortgage, or disposition of substantially all corporate assets, the complaint must […]

When a Corporation Can Reduce Capital Stock Without Unanimous Stockholder Consent

The Supreme Court upheld Sinophil’s capital reduction, ruling that Section 38 compliance, not unanimous stockholder consent, controls SEC approval. Minority stockholders cannot block a corporation’s reduction of authorized capital stock merely because they disagree with the business decision, so long as the corporation complies with the statutory requirements, secures the required two-thirds stockholder vote, protects […]

When Corporate Mismanagement Triggers SEC Intervention: Minority Stockholders Can Ask the Regulator to Step In

The Supreme Court upheld SEC power to investigate corporate mismanagement and create a management committee despite intra-corporate allegations. Minority stockholders are not confined to ordinary intra-corporate litigation when alleged corporate mismanagement threatens company assets, public interest, or the survival of the business itself. The Supreme Court recognized that the Securities and Exchange Commission may still […]

Dissenting Stockholders Cannot Force a Buyout Unless the Corporation Has Retained Earnings

Dissenting stockholders may demand fair value, but payment is enforceable only when the corporation has unrestricted retained earnings to protect creditors. A dissenting stockholder’s appraisal right is not an automatic right to immediate cash. Even after a valid objection to a corporate amendment and even after an appraisal committee fixes the fair value of the […]

When Corporate Property Is Misused, Minority Stockholders May Sue Where the Company Is Based

Minority stockholders may file derivative suits at the corporation’s principal office when insiders allegedly misuse corporate property and board action is futile. Minority stockholders are not powerless when controlling insiders allegedly mortgage, encumber, or allow the foreclosure of corporate property without authority. If the injury belongs to the corporation and the board is unwilling or […]

Buying One Share Does Not Open a Bank’s Books: Good Faith Limits on Stockholder Inspection Rights

A one-share stockholder cannot inspect bank records without good faith, legitimate purpose, and compliance with special charter confidentiality limits. A stockholder’s right to inspect corporate records is powerful, but it is not a license to buy a token share merely to investigate past transactions, gather litigation material, or pry into confidential bank affairs unrelated to […]