When a Club Enforces Its Rules, Hurt Feelings Alone Do Not Create a Damages Case

A valid club suspension caused no compensable injury where members violated rules and failed to prove bad faith, fault, or negligence by the board. Private clubs, associations, and corporations may discipline members who violate valid internal rules, and a suspended member cannot recover millions in moral or exemplary damages merely by showing embarrassment, inconvenience, or […]

When Store Security Goes Too Far: False Shoplifting Accusations Can Create Civil Liability

A supermarket may investigate suspected shoplifting, but public humiliation and false accusation can trigger moral damages when the facts show innocent mistake. Retailers may protect their goods, but they cannot turn loss prevention into public humiliation. A customer wrongly accused of shoplifting may recover damages when store personnel detain, interrogate, shame, or penalize him without […]

When Lost Earnings Are Computed from Net Income, Not Gross Salary

Lost earning capacity in wrongful death cases is based on net income, not gross salary, after deducting living expenses. Families claiming damages for the wrongful death of a breadwinner cannot simply multiply the victim’s full salary by the remaining years of expected life. The recoverable amount for loss of earning capacity is based on net […]

When Broken Railroad Crossing Signals Make the Operator Liable for Lifetime Injury Damages

Railroad operators may be liable for crashes at ungarded crossings when warning devices fail, allowing recovery of medical costs, lost income, moral damages, and fees. Railroad operators may be held liable when they allow trains to pass through a public crossing without working warning devices, without an assigned guard, and without adequate audible warnings, especially […]