When a Judge Gets the Law Wrong: Why Judicial Error Is Not Automatically Misconduct

The Supreme Court held that a judgeโ€™s erroneous or inconsistent order is not misconduct absent gross ignorance, bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, or corruption. Judges may commit reversible error without being administratively punished, so long as the mistake is not a blatant disregard of basic law and is not attended by bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, corruption, […]

A Bad Court Order Is Not Automatically Judicial Misconduct

A wrong or premature court order is not automatically judicial misconduct; litigants must use court remedies unless bad faith or gross error is shown. Litigants who suffer from an adverse or even premature court order cannot immediately convert that grievance into an administrative case against the judge. The controlling doctrine is that judicial remedies must […]

A Defective Motion Can Cost You the Case: When Missing Hearing Notices Make Judgments Final

A defective motion for reconsideration without notice of hearing does not stop the appeal period, allowing the judgment to become final and executory. A party who files a motion for reconsideration without the required notice of hearing may lose the right to appeal entirely, because such a defective motion is treated as a mere scrap […]

A Weak Motion for Reconsideration Can Cost Your Tax Appeal

A generic motion for reconsideration may not stop appeal deadlines. The Court held that a pro forma motion can make a late appeal fatal. Taxpayers and litigants cannot rely on a bare or generic motion for reconsideration to stop appeal deadlines from running. When a motion merely says that the trial court failed to consider […]

A Pending Motion for Reconsideration Can Stop Execution When It Is Not Merely for Delay

A proper motion for reconsideration suspends finality; courts abuse discretion by issuing execution while that motion remains unresolved. A judgment cannot be executed as final while a timely and legally sufficient motion for reconsideration remains unresolved. For litigants, this ruling protects a basic but critical right: a party who properly asks the trial court to […]

When One Judge Is Not Enough: Why Reconsideration Must Be Decided by the Proper Tribunal

A single judge cannot deny reconsideration when the law requires en banc action. The ruling warns taxpayers and businesses to verify proper tribunal authority. A motion for reconsideration is not a mere formality when the law requires a collegial body to act. If a court or administrative tribunal must decide en banc, a ruling issued […]