A Complaint Cannot Be Dismissed Just Because the Defense Disputes the Facts

A complaint survives dismissal when its pleaded facts, if true, show a possible right to relief despite the defendant’s factual denials. A defendant cannot defeat a civil case at the pleading stage merely by insisting that the plaintiff’s story is false. When a motion to dismiss is based on failure to state a cause of […]

One Contract, One Lawsuit: Why Businesses Cannot Split the Same Dispute Across Courts

A later collection case may be dismissed when an earlier case over the same contract is already filed; summons service is not required for lis pendens. Businesses facing a collection dispute cannot avoid an earlier lawsuit by filing a second case in another court over the same contract. When two actions involve the same parties, […]

A Case Cannot Be Dismissed Before the Facts Are Heard

Courts cannot dismiss civil cases on disputed facts without hearing evidence. Borje protects litigants from premature dismissal and denial of due process. Courts cannot short-circuit a lawsuit by dismissing it on disputed factual grounds before the parties are heard. When a complaint raises factual issues requiring proof, especially where both sides disagree on what happened, […]