Judges Are Not Liable for Every Wrong Order: Supreme Court Reaffirms Good Faith Protection in Judicial Decisions

The Supreme Court held that judicial error alone is not misconduct; parties must use appeals or certiorari unless fraud, bad faith, or corruption is proven. A judge’s mistaken ruling is not automatically judicial misconduct. Parties who believe a court order is wrong must ordinarily challenge it through appeal, certiorari, or other judicial remedies—not by turning […]

When a Judge Must Step Aside: Preserving Public Trust in Criminal Proceedings

A judge was fined for setting a bail hearing with improper notice, creating doubt about impartiality and reinforcing when judges should inhibit themselves. Judges who create reasonable doubt about their impartiality may be disciplined even when they later try to correct the error. For litigants, the ruling underscores a practical protection: courts must not only […]

When a Judge Handles a Criminal Case Without Authority, the Case Can Go Off Track Before Trial Even Begins

A judge was fined for conducting an unauthorized preliminary investigation and proceeding without the prosecutor, reinforcing strict limits on criminal procedure. Criminal proceedings may be derailed when a judge takes procedural steps that the court has no authority to take, especially at the preliminary investigation and arraignment stages. For accused persons, complainants, and even taxpayers […]

When a Judge Appears Biased: Why Impartiality Must Be Seen, Not Just Claimed

Judges may be disciplined when their conduct creates an appearance of favoritism, but adverse rulings alone do not prove misconduct without bad faith. Litigants are entitled not only to a judge who is actually fair, but to a courtroom where fairness is visible from the record, the proceedings, and the judge’s conduct. When a judge’s […]

When a Judge Must Step Aside: Family Ties Can Destroy Confidence in a Criminal Case

A judge related to a party must inhibit before acting. Later withdrawal after arrest or failed settlement does not cure the due process problem. A party facing a criminal complaint may question a judge’s participation when the judge is related to one of the parties within the prohibited degree, because judicial neutrality is not only […]