When Prosecutors File in the Wrong Court, Accused Persons Can Demand Accountability

Libel cases must be filed in the RTC. Prosecutors may be disciplined for continuing a case in a court with no jurisdiction. Prosecutors cannot keep a criminal case alive in a court that plainly has no jurisdiction. When the law clearly assigns a crime to a particular court, an accused person may challenge the case […]

A Criminal Case Cannot Be Thrown Out Before the Prosecution Presents Its Evidence

The Court held that weak evidence cannot justify dismissal before trial; a motion to quash tests the charge, not the prosecution’s proof. Criminal defendants may challenge a defective charge early, but they cannot convert a motion to quash into a premature trial on the evidence. In People v. Dumlao, the Court drew a firm line […]

A Dismissed Criminal Case Can Come Back Before Arraignment

A pre-arraignment dismissal may still be revived: no plea means no double jeopardy, and prior preliminary investigation can satisfy due process. A criminal case dismissed before arraignment is not necessarily over. When the accused has not yet pleaded to the charge, prosecutors may still seek reconsideration, the Tanodbayan may reverse a prior recommendation to dismiss, […]

When a Charge Names the Wrong Law: Why Courts Cannot Dismiss If the Facts Still Show a Crime

A wrong legal label will not automatically defeat a criminal case if the information’s facts still allege conduct punishable by law. Criminal cases should not be thrown out merely because the prosecutor cited the wrong or incomplete legal provision, if the facts alleged in the information clearly describe an act punishable by law. For accused […]