When a City Creates a New Business Tax, It Can Take Effect the Next Quarter

A new city business tax may take effect the next quarter, but changes to existing license taxes may be delayed. Classification controls refund rights. A city may collect a newly created business tax as early as the next quarter after the ordinance is enacted, but it cannot immediately enforce an ordinance that merely increases or […]

When a Local License Tax Becomes an Illegal Sales Tax

Municipalities cannot disguise prohibited sales-based taxes as license fees. The Supreme Court voided Mandaue’s levy and ordered refund to San Miguel. Municipalities may charge businesses license taxes, but they cannot disguise a prohibited tax on sales as a licensing fee. For manufacturers and distributors, the key lesson is practical: when a local ordinance computes a […]

When Local Governments Can Tax Your Business Twice: The Supreme Court’s Rule on Municipal Sales and License Taxes

Local governments may impose business taxes and license fees under broad taxing powers; taxpayers must prove invalidity, oppression, or unlawful double taxation. Businesses cannot defeat a local tax ordinance merely by saying the charge feels duplicative, burdensome, or unfair. Under the Local Autonomy Act, cities and municipalities may impose broad local taxes for public purposes, […]

When a Local Tax Ordinance Cannot Override a Franchise Tax Exemption

A city tax ordinance may be valid generally, but unenforceable against a franchise holder expressly exempt from local taxes beyond its franchise tax. A city may have broad authority to impose local license taxes, but that power stops where Congress has granted a franchise holder a specific exemption from all taxes except the franchise tax. […]