A Missing Murder Weapon Does Not Defeat Eyewitness Testimony, But Uncharged Aggravating Facts Cannot Raise the Penalty

Eyewitness testimony can sustain a murder conviction even without the weapon, but uncharged aggravating facts cannot justify the death penalty. A murder conviction may stand even when the firearm is never recovered, if credible eyewitnesses positively identify the assailant and their testimony is consistent with the physical evidence. But the penalty cannot be pushed to […]

One Credible Eyewitness Can Defeat an Alibi in a Murder Case

A murder conviction may rest on one credible eyewitness when positive identification defeats denial and alibi, and treachery is proven by a sudden attack. A murder conviction may stand on the testimony of a single credible eyewitness when that testimony is natural, straightforward, and consistent on material points; denial and alibi will not prevail where […]

A Guilty Plea Cannot Supply Missing Aggravating Circumstances in a Criminal Case

A guilty plea cannot cure missing allegations or proof. The Court reduced a murder penalty after rejecting unalleged and unproven aggravating circumstances. Even when an accused admits killing another person, the prosecution must still prove the exact crime charged and the penalty-enhancing facts alleged in the information. A guilty plea, standing alone, cannot cure a […]

Positive Identification Beats Alibi: What Manalo Teaches About Criminal Defense in the Philippines

Clear eyewitness identification can defeat an alibi. Manalo affirms that minor inconsistencies and lack of motive do not automatically create reasonable doubt. When eyewitnesses clearly identify the accused as the person who committed the crime, a defense of alibi will usually fail unless it is so strong that it makes the accusedโ€™s presence at the […]

You Cannot Be Convicted of Murder When the Charge Only Says Homicide

An accused charged only with homicide cannot be convicted of murder unless the qualifying circumstance is alleged in the information. A person accused of homicide cannot be sentenced for murder unless the facts that legally make the killing murder are clearly alleged in the criminal information. The constitutional right to be informed of the nature […]

When a Witness Changes Details but the Core Story Holds: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Rule on Credibility and Minor Inconsistencies

The Court affirmed a murder conviction, holding that affidavit omissions do not defeat credible courtroom testimony when the witnessโ€™s core account remains reliable. Criminal convictions do not fall simply because a witness gives a prior statement that is less complete than her testimony in court. When the trial judge personally hears the witnesses, observes their […]

Eyewitness Testimony Can Convict Even Without Motive or Perfect Alibi

Positive identification by credible witnesses can defeat alibi and lack of motive defenses in murder cases, especially when physical impossibility is not proven. A criminal conviction may stand even when the defense attacks the witnessโ€™s exact vantage point, claims lack of motive, or presents an alibi, if the courts find that the accused were positively […]

When Witnesses Disagree on Details, Can a Murder Conviction Still Stand?

Witness inconsistencies on minor details do not defeat a murder conviction when positive identification and the nature of the wounds prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction may still stand even when eyewitnesses disagree on minor details, so long as their testimony points to the same essential truth: the accused participated in the attack. […]