Audited Financial Statements and Tax Returns Can Defeat an Illegal Dismissal Claim When Retrenchment Is Real

Audited financial statements and tax returns helped prove real losses, defeating an illegal dismissal claim based on alleged forced resignation. Employers facing illegal dismissal claims may rely on audited financial statements and income tax returns to prove that a retrenchment plan was genuine, but only when those records show real business losses and support a […]

Tax Returns Alone Cannot Justify Retrenchment: Employers Must Prove Real Business Losses Before Dismissing Workers

Tax returns alone did not save a retrenchment defense. The Court restored reinstatement and backwages after workers were denied a fair chance to contest late evidence. Employees retrenched for alleged business losses may challenge the dismissal when the employer relies on financial documents presented only on appeal and without giving workers a fair chance to […]

No Second Bite at Certiorari: Final Supreme Court Rulings Bind Parties Who Already Had Their Day in Court

The Court dismissed a repeat certiorari petition because the same administrative decision had already been reviewed, reinforcing finality in tax and labor disputes. A party cannot keep relitigating the same administrative decision by changing procedural posture or filing a new petition after the Supreme Court has already passed upon the issue. For taxpayers, employers, unions, […]