Government-Owned Corporations Without Original Charters Are Sued in the NLRC, Not the Civil Service Commission

Employees of government-owned corporations without original charters may file illegal dismissal claims before the NLRC, not the Civil Service Commission. Employees of a government-owned or controlled corporation do not automatically fall under Civil Service Commission jurisdiction. Where the corporation has no original charter and was incorporated under the general corporation law, its employment disputes belong […]

When a Vice President Is Ousted, the Case May Belong to the SEC β€” Not the Labor Arbiter

Corporate officers elected under by-laws may need to challenge removal as an intra-corporate dispute, not an NLRC illegal dismissal case. Corporate officers who are removed from positions created by a corporation’s by-laws may not always have an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the labor tribunals. Where the dispute is inseparably tied to the election, appointment, […]

Employers Cannot Deduct Uncalled Stock Subscriptions From Wages

Employers cannot offset final pay with unpaid stock subscriptions unless the corporate debt is due, properly called, and deductible under labor law. Employees who are also shareholders do not automatically lose their wages to alleged unpaid stock subscriptions. Before an employer may withhold or offset salary, benefits, or allowances, the claim must belong in the […]

Labor Disputes with Damage Claims Belong Before Labor Arbiters, Not Regular Courts

Damage claims tied to unfair labor practice remain within labor arbiter jurisdiction, even when pleaded as civil tort claims or linked to a corporate merger. Employees and unions cannot move an unfair labor practice case to a regular court simply by asking for damages, injunction, or civil-law remedies. When the injury arises from alleged interference […]

When a Case Becomes Moot, Courts Will Not Give Advisory Opinions

Courts will not decide moot disputes or issue advisory opinions after legal changes erase the live controversy, a rule relevant to tax and regulatory cases. Courts will not decide a dispute that has lost its practical effect, even when the original legal question was important. For taxpayers, regulated businesses, employers, and government agencies, the practical […]

When a Labor Case Becomes Moot After the Court Handling It Is Abolished

Pending labor cases before an abolished tribunal may become moot when the Labor Code transfers unresolved disputes to the new NLRC framework. Pending labor disputes can become moot when the legal body handling them is abolished and the governing law transfers all unresolved cases to a new labor tribunal. For employers and employees, the practical […]