When a Taxpayer Owes Zero, Its Franchise Tax Exemption Can Still Apply

The Supreme Court held that PAL’s franchise exemption applied despite zero tax liability, allowing refund of overseas communications tax paid. A franchise tax exemption can operate even when the taxpayer pays nothing because it suffered losses. For businesses holding special legislative franchises, the key lesson is that the legal consequence may turn not on actual […]

In-Lieu-of-All-Taxes Rule: Why PAL Recovered OCT Refunds

Special franchise taxpayers may recover OCT when an in-lieu-of-all-taxes clause clearly exempts them despite zero income tax liability. The in-lieu-of-all-taxes rule protects a franchise holder from being charged additional national or local taxes when its franchise law gives it a clear election between specified tax alternatives. For businesses operating under special franchises, the most important […]