When Public Funds Claims Fail Without Evidence: Coco Levy Shares and the Burden of Proof

The Court held that alleged public funds must be traced with competent proof before shares can be forfeited as ill-gotten wealth. Government claims over alleged ill-gotten assets can fail even where the controversy involves public funds, political influence, and massive corporate shareholdings, if the State cannot prove the essential link between the disputed property and […]

When Stock Transfers, Tax Payments, and Nominee Claims Decide Ownership of Sequestered Shares

The Court upheld a stock sale supported by indorsed certificates, tax payment, and records, while forfeiting proven nominee-held shares as ill-gotten wealth. Corporate share ownership is not defeated merely because there is no separate deed of sale. In a dispute over sequestered shares, the Supreme Court reaffirmed a practical rule that matters to business owners, […]

When PCGG Sequestration Disputes Must Go to the Sandiganbayan

PCGG-related corporate disputes tied to sequestration belong before the Sandiganbayan, but shareholders retain inspection rights in sequestered firms. Businesses and shareholders affected by PCGG sequestration cannot split related disputes among different forums: challenges to PCGG acts, board takeovers, corporate records, injunctions, and related provisional remedies must generally be brought before the Sandiganbayan when they arise […]