Missed Appeal Deadlines Can Make Tax Refund and Tax Credit Victories Final

A late government appeal made a CTA refund or tax credit victory final, with service on the OSG controlling the appeal deadline. Taxpayers who win a refund or tax credit case before a CTA Division may be able to rely on that victory becoming final when the Commissioner fails to perfect an appeal on time, […]

Tax Ruling Collateral Attack Rule: Why RTCs Cannot Stop Tax Collection

Taxpayers cannot use RTC cases to indirectly attack BIR rulings when the real issue is national tax liability or tax collection. Taxpayers cannot avoid a BIR ruling by filing a separate case in a regular trial court against the agency document used as the ruling’s factual basis. Under the tax ruling collateral attack rule, when […]

PAL MCIT Exemption Rule: When Franchise Tax Options Defeat MCIT

Special franchise taxpayers may defeat MCIT when the law gives a lower-tax option and an in-lieu-of-all-other-taxes clause. The PAL MCIT Exemption Rule protects a taxpayer with a special legislative franchise from being forced into the minimum corporate income tax when its franchise gives it a narrower and more favorable tax choice. For companies operating under […]

When a Taxpayer Owes Zero, Its Franchise Tax Exemption Can Still Apply

The Supreme Court held that PAL’s franchise exemption applied despite zero tax liability, allowing refund of overseas communications tax paid. A franchise tax exemption can operate even when the taxpayer pays nothing because it suffered losses. For businesses holding special legislative franchises, the key lesson is that the legal consequence may turn not on actual […]