Mandanas Doctrine: LGU Shares Must Come From All National Taxes

LGU shares must be computed from all national taxes, but past arrears are barred under the prospective Mandanas Doctrine. The Mandanas Doctrine changed the fiscal baseline for local governments: the constitutional share of provinces, cities, municipalities, and barangays must be computed from all national taxes, not only national internal revenue taxes. For local officials, taxpayers, […]

Public Funds Public Purpose Rule: Private Gains From Levy Funds Voided

Public levy funds cannot become private wealth; UCPB shares bought with coconut levy funds were ordered returned to the Philippine government. The Public Funds Public Purpose Rule means that money collected by government through levies or taxes cannot be converted into private wealth, even through a contract that appears formally valid. For businesses, public agencies, […]

Exclusive Calling-Out Powers: Why Local Emergency Orders Can Be Void

Local officials cannot call out the military, form armed civilian forces, or authorize general searches through local emergency orders. Exclusive Calling-Out Powers mean that a governor, mayor, or other local official cannot unilaterally summon the military, create armed civilian forces, or authorize general searches merely by declaring a local emergency. For individuals, constitutional rights do […]

When Government Wants Free Ad Space: The Supreme Court’s Rule on Taking Private Property for Elections

Government cannot compel newspapers to provide free election ad space without just compensation, even for voter education and public-interest purposes. Private publishers, media companies, and business owners cannot be forced to give the government free use of their property merely because the government’s purpose is public, civic, or election-related. The Constitution allows the State to […]

Public Utility Ownership Divide: SC Upholds EDSA LRT III Contract

Foreign ownership of infrastructure assets is not public utility operation when government runs the service; EDSA LRT III contract upheld. The public utility ownership divide doctrine matters to infrastructure investors, government contractors, and public-private partnership participants because it confirms that owning facilities used for public service is not always the same as operating a public […]

CARP Just Compensation Rule: Land Reform Upheld, Payment Required

Agrarian reform takings are valid, but landowners retain title until full just compensation is paid, protecting property owners in Philippine CARP disputes. The CARP Just Compensation Rule protects both sides of agrarian reform: the State may redistribute private agricultural land for a constitutional public purpose, but ownership cannot be finally transferred away from the landowner […]