Tax Compromise Acquittal Rule: Why SC Protected Final Judgments

A BIR tax compromise approved in good faith cannot support graft liability once acquittal stands, absent grave abuse or denial of due process. The Tax Compromise Acquittal Rule protects public officers and accused persons from renewed criminal exposure when a competent court has already acquitted them, unless the State can show grave abuse of discretion […]

When a Victimโ€™s Clear Testimony Is Enough to Convict for Rape โ€” and Why Attempted Rape Still Requires Proof of Intent

Victim testimony may sustain a rape conviction, but attempted rape requires proof of overt acts directly beginning sexual intercourse. A rape conviction may rest on the victimโ€™s credible, straightforward testimony even without fresh injuries or dramatic physical evidence, but an attempted rape charge still fails unless the prosecution proves that the accused had already begun […]

When a Childโ€™s Testimony Is Enough to Convict: The Mahinay Rule on Rape, Consent, and Credibility

A childโ€™s credible testimony can sustain a rape conviction despite minor inconsistencies, delayed reporting, and alibi when material facts prove force, intimidation, or statutory rape. A rape conviction may stand on the clear and credible testimony of a child complainant even when there are minor inconsistencies in her account, especially where the accused used threats, […]

Cebu Drug Cases with Lower Penalties Must Go to a Designated Special Court

Cebu City drug cases with penalties lower than death were centralized in RTC Branch 10 to speed up proceedings and guide pending and future case assignments. Drug prosecutions in Cebu City involving offenses under the Dangerous Drugs Act, where the imposable penalty is lower than death, must be routed to a designated special court rather […]

Conspiracy by Concerted Acts: When Joint Action Proves Guilt

Conspiracy may be proven by coordinated acts, not a written plan, and minor witness inconsistencies do not defeat criminal conviction. Conspiracy by concerted acts means that prosecutors do not always need a written agreement, direct admission, or formal plan to prove that several accused acted as one. In criminal litigation, coordinated conduct before, during, and […]

A Confession Alone Is Not Enough: How Corpus Delicti Protects the Accused in Criminal Trials

A confession alone cannot convict without independent proof that the crime occurred, but conspiracy can make a lookout liable for robbery with homicide. A criminal conviction cannot rest on a confession standing alone. Before an out-of-court admission may support guilt, prosecutors must first prove that a crime actually happened through evidence independent of the confession. […]

When a Judgeโ€™s Leniency Is Not Misconduct: The Good-Faith Adjudication Rule

Judges are not disciplined merely for lenient rulings when the record supports their action and no rule violation, irregularity, or bias is shown. A losing or disappointed litigant cannot turn every unfavorable courtroom decision into an administrative case against the judge. The doctrine from Tolentino v. Judge Tiong is a practical one: judicial discipline requires […]