Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Liable for Employee Money Claims

Corporate officers are not automatically liable for employee money claims without summons, due process, and proof of bad faith or statutory grounds. Company presidents, directors, and managers cannot be made personally liable for labor money claims merely because the corporation closed, failed to pay employees, or may no longer have assets to satisfy a judgment. […]

Corporate Rehabilitation Can Freeze Employee Money Claims Before the NLRC

Employee money claims before the NLRC may be suspended when the employer is under SEC-supervised rehabilitation and a management committee is appointed. Employee money claims may be temporarily halted when the employer is under SEC-supervised rehabilitation and a management committee has been appointed. For workers, this means that illegal dismissal, damages, attorneyโ€™s fees, and wage-related […]

When a Firing Is Really a Corporate Dispute: Stockholder-Officers Must Go to the Corporate Forum, Not the NLRC

Stockholder-officers alleging illegal dismissal may be outside NLRC jurisdiction when the dispute is truly intra-corporate and rooted in corporate management. Corporate officers who are also stockholders cannot automatically frame their removal as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the NLRC. When the dispute arises from their status as directors, officers, or stockholders, and the controversy […]

Labor Disputes Cannot Be Repackaged as Civil Damage Cases

Civil courts cannot hear damages suits or issue injunctions when the dispute is rooted in unfair labor practice, union activity, or picketing. Employers cannot avoid the labor forum by filing a civil damages case when the dispute is rooted in alleged unfair labor practices, union activity, or picketing. When the acts complained of are intertwined […]

Work-Related Illness Claims: When the Employer Must Disprove Compensability

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer disproves it with substantial evidence, the Court held in Enriquez. Employees who became ill while still employed under the former Workmenโ€™s Compensation regime did not have to prove medical causation from scratch; once the illness appeared or worsened during employment, the law presumed it compensable […]

Reinstatement Does Not Always Mean Backwages: When Labor Tribunals Must Explain Why Pay Is Denied

Reinstatement does not always mean backwages, but labor tribunals must explain any denial with clear facts, especially in abandonment or transfer disputes. Employees who win reinstatement do not automatically win backwages in every labor dispute, but a labor tribunal cannot deny backwages through a bare or ambiguous order. When the record is thin, especially where […]

A Closed Business May Still Owe Back Wages When Its Own Records Show Continued Operations

Employers cannot cut off back wage liability by merely claiming closure when records show continued operations or a connected successor enterprise. Employers cannot defeat a back wage award simply by declaring that the business had already closed if the record shows continued operations, asset transfers, or a successor arrangement pointing to the same enterprise. Community […]

When Non-Union Employees Cannot Be Charged Union Lawyerโ€™s Fees

Non-union supervisors who received employer-extended wage increases could not be charged union lawyerโ€™s fees without representation, consent, or CBA coverage. Employees who receive wage increases because their employer voluntarily extends benefits across the company cannot automatically be made to pay the union lawyer who negotiated those benefits for another group. The doctrine is simple but […]

When Employers Miss the Deadline, Work Injury Claims Can Become Much Harder to Defeat

Illness arising during employment may be presumed compensable, and employers who fail to timely controvert can waive defenses against the claim. Employers who fail to timely controvert a workmenโ€™s compensation claim may lose key defenses, and illnesses that appear during employment may be presumed compensable unless the employer can prove otherwise with substantial evidence. For […]

When Illness Appears at Work, Compensation Cannot Be Denied by Speculation

Illness during employment may be presumed compensable once a work link appears, shifting the burden to the employer to disprove work connection. An employee who becomes ill during the period of employment does not have to prove the full medical mechanics of how the job caused the disease before compensation may be awarded. Once a […]