When Court Delay Is Not Neglect: The Supreme Court’s Practical Rule on eRaffle Backlogs and Administrative Liability

Court eRaffle delays do not automatically prove neglect; liability requires carelessness, bad faith, or breach of duty, but false surety clearances may still be punishable. Judges and court personnel are not automatically administratively liable simply because a new court technology causes case raffle delays. The decisive question is whether the delay was caused by carelessness, […]

Court Employees Cannot Hand Case Evidence to a Party’s Relative

Court staff may be disciplined for giving disputed evidence to a party’s relative, even without proof of tampering, if the act compromises court neutrality. Judicial personnel who handle court records, subpoenas, and documentary evidence are not mere clerical actors; they are custodians of the court’s neutrality. When a court employee gives disputed evidence to a […]