Can a Litigant Be Ordered to Produce Income Tax Returns in a Civil Case?

A taxpayer claiming lost income may be ordered to produce ITRs; broad tax confidentiality claims and improper Rule 65 remedies will not stop trial evidence. A taxpayer who puts lost income at issue in a civil case may not automatically defeat a court order to produce personal income tax returns by invoking tax confidentiality. When […]

Why Employees Can Be Taxed Differently From Professionals and Business Owners

Employees may be taxed differently from professionals and business owners if Congress uses reasonable classifications and applies them uniformly within each class. Taxpayers cannot defeat an income tax law merely by showing that employees, professionals, and business owners are not taxed in exactly the same way. When Congress creates tax brackets or separates classes of […]

When Can a Taxpayer Sue Over Government Spending? The Cultural Center Ruling Draws the Line

Taxpayer suits require a direct link to tax-funded public spending; donated funds and later curative legislation defeated the challenge to the Cultural Center. A taxpayer cannot automatically challenge every government-backed project simply by alleging misuse of public resources; the taxpayer must show that the challenged act involves public funds raised through taxation, or at least […]