CWT Refund Denied: Taxpayers Must Trace Withheld Income to Reported Gross Revenue

A CWT refund claim was denied despite timely filing because the taxpayer failed to trace withheld income payments to gross income reported in its annual return. Corporate taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit certificate for excess creditable withholding taxes must do more than present BIR Forms 2307 and show that total reported revenues exceed […]

Zero-Rated VAT Refunds Survive If Receipts Clearly Show VAT Zero-Rated Sales

VAT refund claim partly upheld where receipts showed VAT zero-rated sales, but CAS permit-based input VAT was disallowed for lack of proof. VAT refund claimants cannot rely on assumptions about computerized accounting system permits, but they may still defend a zero-rated sales refund where the receipts themselves clearly show that the transactions are VAT zero-rated. […]

Late-Served BIR Assessment Notices Can Void VAT and EWT Assessments

A late-served BIR assessment notice with an expired payment deadline can violate due process and void VAT and EWT assessments despite valid waivers. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency assessments should check not only the amount assessed, but also the date the assessment was actually served and whether the BIR meaningfully addressed their protest arguments. A formal […]

Capital Gains Tax Refunds Need Clear Payment Proof to Survive BIR Challenge

A taxpayer kept its capital gains tax refund after proving payment through BIR Form 1707, PhilPass records, and BIR certification despite the Commissionerโ€™s challenge. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit certificate for erroneously paid capital gains tax must be prepared to prove the actual payment with competent records. In this ruling, the taxpayer preserved […]

Export VAT Refunds Can Fail Without Proof of Actual Foreign Sales

A VAT refund claim was denied because BOI export registration did not prove actual zero-rated export sales linked to the claimed input VAT. VAT-registered exporters seeking refunds or tax credit certificates for unutilized input VAT must prove more than export registration status. A taxpayer claiming that its purchases are attributable to zero-rated export sales must […]

Acquittal Upheld: Drivers Not Liable for Excise Tax on Untaxed Cigarettes

CTA upholds acquittal of driver Victor Gaw Sy; individuals not owners or importers cannot be held liable for excise taxes on untaxed cigarettes. Taxpayers and logistics operators can take note: individuals who are merely drivers or custodians of goods cannot automatically be held liable for excise taxes unless they are proven to be owners or […]

Government Agencies Cannot Bring BIR Assessment Disputes Directly to the Tax Court

A government agencyโ€™s BIR assessment appeal was dismissed because intra-governmental tax disputes must be administratively settled under PD 242. National government agencies facing BIR deficiency tax assessments cannot assume that an ordinary appeal to the tax court will be heard, because disputes solely between government entities must first pass through the administrative settlement system under […]

Commercial Invoices Alone Cannot Win a VAT Refund for Export Sales

Exporters claiming input VAT refunds must prove zero-rated sales with valid VAT sales invoices, not commercial invoices alone. Exporters seeking VAT refunds must prove zero-rated sales with the correct VAT sales invoices, not merely with commercial invoices used for delivery, monitoring, or export documentation. In this ruling, the taxpayerโ€™s claim for a Php2.087 million refund […]

Taxpayer Denied Relief Over Missed Formal Letter of Demand Protest

The CTA denied petitioner’s motion for reconsideration after confirming proper service of the FLD/FAN, emphasizing timely protest is critical to preserve appeal rights. Businesses and individual taxpayers must be vigilant in filing timely protests against Formal Letters of Demand (FLD) or Assessment Notices to preserve their right to appeal, as missing this crucial step can […]

Filing Deadlines Are Jurisdictional: One-Day Delay Costs LBC Express Its Tax Appeal

LBC Express’s tax appeal was dismissed due to a one-day late filing, highlighting the jurisdictional importance of timely petitions before the CTA. Taxpayers and corporate counsel should take note: strict adherence to filing deadlines for petitions before the Court of Tax Appeals is not optional. In a recent resolution involving LBC Express-SEM, Inc., the Court […]