Judges May Defend Their Reputation, But Not Through Unapproved Press Conferences

A judge was cleared over alleged search warrant delay but fined for improper public conduct, media statements, and unapproved press activity. Judges are not administratively liable merely because they take time to examine a search warrant application, ask searching questions, or insist on proof of probable cause. But when a judge publicly intrudes into legislative […]

Search Warrants for Tax Violations Require More Than Unpaid Purchase Prices

Judges must find probable cause for the specific tax offense charged before issuing a search warrant; non-payment alone cannot justify seizure. Tax-related search warrants cannot rest on a bare allegation that someone failed to pay for imported goods, duties, or taxes; a judge must personally determine probable cause for the specific tax or customs offense […]

Tax Raids Need Judicial Scrutiny: Why BIR Search Warrants Cannot Be Fishing Expeditions

Tax search warrants must name one specific offense, be personally examined by a judge, and clearly identify records to be seized. Businesses facing tax investigations are not stripped of constitutional protection merely because the government suspects unpaid taxes. In Bache & Co., the Supreme Court made clear that a tax search warrant must be issued […]