Hierarchy of Courts Rule: Why Direct SC Petitions Can Fail

Direct SC petitions against government contracts need special reasons; fact-heavy PPP challenges belong in the proper lower forum. The hierarchy of courts rule remains a serious litigation barrier even in constitutional cases: parties challenging government infrastructure contracts must show special and important reasons before going directly to the Supreme Court, especially when the dispute requires […]

A Cooperative Branch Cannot Sue Like a Separate Company

A cooperative branch with no juridical personality cannot sue or defeat a regulator-approved franchise transfer through an internal compromise agreement. A branch office, operating unit, or internal division cannot claim corporate powers merely because it has its own name, accounts, or operational control. In this ruling, the Court treated that distinction as decisive: MAGELCO-PALMA was […]

When Public Utilities Must Share Infrastructure: NTC Power to Require Telecom Interconnection

The Court upheld NTC authority to grant provisional telecom operations and require interconnection despite PLDTโ€™s objections, limiting certiorari review. A public utility franchise does not create a private fortress. When public need, competition, and nationwide service are at stake, the National Telecommunications Commission may allow a new telecom operator to begin limited operations and require […]