Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Stockholders Skip Appraisal Rights Allegations

Stockholders’ derivative suit over a corporate mortgage was dismissed for failing to plead appraisal rights and non-harassment requirements. Stockholders who sue in the corporation’s name cannot treat a derivative suit as a shortcut around corporate remedies. When the challenged corporate act involves the sale, mortgage, or disposition of substantially all corporate assets, the complaint must […]

Co-Ownership and Torrens Title Doctrine: Supreme Court Upholds Indefeasible Ownership

The SC ruled that the Torrens title of Iluminado Baloloy prevails; all indispensable co-owners must be joined, and insufficient evidence cannot overturn a registered title. Property owners in the Philippines can now rely more firmly on the legal strength of Torrens titles, even against claims of long-standing possession or verbal agreements, provided all co-owners are […]

A Mortgage Does Not Let You Keep the Property: Why Ownership Still Controls Possession

A mortgage secures a loan but does not transfer possession. The owner may recover the property unless the mortgage expressly grants possessory rights. A person who lends money secured by real property does not automatically gain the right to occupy, hold, or refuse to surrender that property. Unless the mortgage contract expressly gives possession to […]

A Tax Declaration Cannot Turn Someone Else’s House Into Your Property

Tax declarations do not create ownership. The Court protected heirs who owned a house excluded from a land sale and ordered proper assessment in their name. A tax declaration is not a shortcut to ownership. A landowner who manages to have a house declared for tax purposes in its own name does not thereby acquire […]

Tax Declarations Can Support Possession, But They Cannot Save a Weak Land Claim

Tax declarations may support possession claims, but Querubin shows they cannot defeat stronger title evidence, boundaries, and older registered possessory rights. Tax declarations can help prove a land claimant’s good-faith assertion of ownership, but they do not automatically defeat older possession, stronger boundaries, or documentary gaps. For property owners and litigants, Querubin teaches a practical […]

Tax Declarations Do Not Defeat a Landowner’s Right to Prove Ownership

Tax declarations and old deeds may support land claims, but they do not bar ownership suits unless the admission clearly covers the exact disputed property. A land buyer is not automatically barred from proving ownership merely because an earlier deed or pleading appears to acknowledge another person’s title. For taxpayers and property owners, the ruling […]