Self-Defense in Murder Cases Requires Proof, Not Just a Story

An accused who admits a killing must prove self-defense by clear and convincing evidence; minor witness inconsistencies will not undo a murder conviction. A person who admits killing another cannot escape criminal liability by simply saying he acted in self-defense. Once self-defense is invoked, the burden shifts: the accused must prove, by clear and convincing […]

Voice and Physique Can Be Enough: How Courts Treat Identification in Rape Cases

A rape conviction may stand on credible identification by voice, physique, and appearance, while alibi fails unless it proves physical impossibility at the crime scene. A rape conviction may stand even when the victim did not immediately know the attacker’s name, so long as the prosecution proves that she later identified him through reliable features […]

When Fear Freezes a Victim: Why Failure to Resist Does Not Defeat a Rape Case

Fear-based submission is not consent. The Court affirmed a rape conviction despite lack of successful resistance and rejected an unsupported sweetheart defense. A rape victim’s failure to fight back, shout for help, or immediately escape does not automatically mean consent. When intimidation, threats, physical disparity, or fear prevents resistance, the law treats submission as coerced, […]

When a Victim’s Testimony Alone Can Convict: The Supreme Court’s Rule on Credibility, Fear, and Damages in Rape Cases

Credible victim testimony may sustain a rape conviction despite delayed reporting, imperfect medical findings, and unsupported sweetheart defenses. A rape conviction may rest on the credible testimony of the victim alone, even without perfect medical findings, immediate reporting, or the prosecution of every possible witness. For accused persons and complainants alike, People v. Dagami is […]

When a Criminal Information Fails to Allege Relationship, the Death Penalty Cannot Stand

Rape conviction affirmed, but death penalty reduced because the information failed to allege the precise qualifying relationship required by law. A person charged with rape cannot be sentenced to the gravest qualifying penalty unless the facts that make the crime qualified are expressly alleged in the criminal information. Even where the evidence proves a close […]

A Missing Murder Weapon Does Not Defeat Eyewitness Testimony, But Uncharged Aggravating Facts Cannot Raise the Penalty

Eyewitness testimony can sustain a murder conviction even without the weapon, but uncharged aggravating facts cannot justify the death penalty. A murder conviction may stand even when the firearm is never recovered, if credible eyewitnesses positively identify the assailant and their testimony is consistent with the physical evidence. But the penalty cannot be pushed to […]

Child Rape, Delayed Disclosure, and the Rule That Fear Does Not Defeat Credibility

Child rape conviction affirmed despite delayed disclosure, but death penalty removed because the qualifying relationship was not properly alleged in the Information. A child’s silence after sexual abuse does not automatically weaken her case, especially where fear, intimidation, family pressure, or psychological trauma explains the delayed disclosure. In Negosa, the Court reaffirmed that rape prosecutions […]

When Conviction Stands but the Death Penalty Falls: Why Relationship Must Be Strictly Proven in Rape Cases

Rape conviction affirmed, but death penalty reduced because the qualifying relationship was not strictly alleged and proven under criminal law. A rape conviction may rest on the clear, credible, and detailed testimony of the victim, but a higher penalty cannot be imposed unless every qualifying circumstance is both properly alleged and independently proven. For accused […]

When the Charge Is Defective, the Penalty Cannot Be Upgraded After Trial

The Supreme Court affirmed murder and rape convictions but reduced penalties where homicide was not alleged in the rape information. A criminal conviction may stand even when the accused’s defense fails, but the penalty cannot be increased for a graver crime unless the charging document itself alleges the facts that make that graver crime punishable. […]