When Utilities Cannot Pass Income Tax to Consumers: The MERALCO Rate-Setting Rule

Utilities may earn a fair return, but cannot pass their own income tax to consumers as an operating expense in rate-setting disputes. A public utility cannot treat its own income tax as an operating expense to be recovered from consumers through electricity rates. For regulated businesses, the doctrine is straightforward but powerful: customers may be […]

Express Gambling Franchise Rule: Why PAGCOR Could Not Run Jai-Alai

PAGCOR needed clear legislative authority to operate jai-alai; broad charter language could not imply a gambling franchise. Government gaming authority is not a blank check: under the Express Gambling Franchise Rule, even PAGCOR must point to a clear legislative franchise before operating or authorizing a specific gambling activity such as jai-alai. For businesses dealing with […]

Court-Approved Compromise Can End Business Litigation, But Tax and Regulatory Liabilities Must Still Be Settled

A lawful compromise ended the Mondragon-CDC dispute, but the agreement preserved payment of BIR and PAGCOR liabilities within defined settlement terms. A business dispute can become moot when the parties submit a lawful compromise to the court, but the settlement must still account for regulatory and tax-facing obligations that survive the litigation. For companies operating […]

COMELEC Airtime Rule: When Broadcast Franchises Must Serve Elections

Broadcast franchises may carry election airtime duties; COMELEC Time is a valid public-service burden, not unconstitutional taking. Broadcast networks may be required to give free airtime for election purposes when that obligation is treated as a reasonable burden attached to their public franchise, not as an unconstitutional taking of private property. The COMELEC Airtime Rule […]

Business Permits Do Not Shield Officers From Criminal Liability When the Enterprise Is Unauthorized

A business officer may be personally liable when an unlicensed, unincorporated entity collects money and performs regulated activities without authority. Corporate officers, managers, and promoters cannot hide behind an unregistered or unlicensed business entity when the enterprise itself is used to collect money, promise services, or recruit the public without authority. The ruling in People […]