Non-Extendible MR Rule: Lost Appeals Cannot Be Revived

A motion for reconsideration deadline cannot be extended; lost appeals cannot be revived through certiorari after party negligence. The non-extendible motion for reconsideration rule can end a case before the merits are ever reviewed: a party that misses the 15-day deadline cannot revive its lost remedy by asking for more time, changing lawyers, or filing […]

Filing the Same Property Dispute in Multiple Courts Can Get Your Case Dismissed With Prejudice

Forum shopping in related property cases can lead to dismissal with prejudice, contempt, fines, and lawyer sanctions when parties file overlapping suits in different courts. Litigants cannot improve their chances by filing the same property dispute in different courts and waiting to see which forum appears more favorable. When the same parties, issues, and reliefs […]

A Complaint Cannot Be Dismissed Just Because the Defense Disputes the Facts

A complaint survives dismissal when its pleaded facts, if true, show a possible right to relief despite the defendantโ€™s factual denials. A defendant cannot defeat a civil case at the pleading stage merely by insisting that the plaintiffโ€™s story is false. When a motion to dismiss is based on failure to state a cause of […]

Certiorari Is Not a Shortcut When an Ordinary Appeal Is Available

Certiorari cannot replace an available appeal. Enriquez v. Rivera warns litigants that using the wrong remedy may doom even a serious procedural challenge. Certiorari is an extraordinary remedy, not a second route for a losing litigant who still has an ordinary appeal. For taxpayers, property owners, employers, and businesses challenging adverse court or agency orders, […]

Courts May Relax Filing Deadlines When Strict Procedure Would Defeat Substantial Justice

Courts may relax missed filing deadlines when the delay is justified, non-prejudicial, and strict procedure would defeat substantial justice. Litigants who miss a procedural deadline are not always automatically out of court. When no substantial prejudice is shown and the delay results from circumstances that make strict compliance inequitable, courts may use their inherent power […]

A Technical Defect in an Appeal Record Will Not Defeat a Timely Appeal

A timely appeal should not be dismissed for a technical omission when the record as a whole shows compliance with appeal requirements. A party should not lose the right to appeal merely because the record on appeal omits a technical statement, so long as the record itself shows that the appeal was perfected on time. […]