When Business Invoices Beat Side Deals: Why Written Sales Documents Control in Commercial Tax and Asset Disputes

Signed invoices and sales confirmations controlled over alleged side deals, reinforcing documentation, corporate separateness, and liability rules. Businesses that sign sales invoices, confirmations, and similar commercial documents cannot later escape payment by invoking an alleged side arrangement that is not written into the transaction. The doctrine is simple but powerful: in commercial disputes, written business […]

Foreign Companies Can Sue in the Philippines When They Are Not Doing Business Here

Foreign corporations may sue in Philippine courts without a license if their local activity is not doing business, including certain export-processing arrangements. A foreign corporation is not automatically barred from suing in Philippine courts merely because it has commercial dealings connected to the Philippines. If its local activity is limited, incidental, or confined to export-related […]

Courts Cannot Use Replevin to Pull Seized Forest Products Away From DENR Control

DENR has primary jurisdiction over seized forest products, making replevin improper when courts would preempt environmental enforcement and agency custody. Businesses, vessel owners, consignees, and property claimants cannot simply run to court for replevin when forest products or their conveyances have been seized by environmental authorities. Where the controversy concerns timber or forest products allegedly […]

When Property Is Wrongfully Seized, Replevin Can Force Its Return

Property wrongfully seized in another case may be recovered through replevin, and a timely counterbond can compel return pending final ownership determination. Property owners are not helpless when their movable property is seized in someone elseโ€™s case: a replevin action may be used to recover goods or chattels wrongfully detained, even when the property was […]