A Rape Conviction May Stand Even When the Higher Penalty Fails

A rape conviction may stand despite an imperfect information, but the higher penalty fails when the qualifying relationship was not specifically charged. A criminal conviction can survive a defect in the charge, but the punishment cannot exceed what the accused was properly informed he had to defend against. In rape prosecutions, this means that an […]

Rape Convictions Cannot Rest on a Theory the Accused Was Never Required to Defend Against

Rape conviction reversed because the prosecution failed to prove the charged mode of force or intimidation and could not rely on an uncharged theory. A criminal conviction must stand or fall on the charge actually made, not on a different theory discovered only after trial. In People v. Mendigurin, the Supreme Court acquitted an accused […]