When Circumstantial Evidence Is Enough to Convict: Lessons from the Lozada Robbery with Homicide Ruling

Circumstantial evidence can sustain a robbery with homicide conviction when proven facts form an unbroken chain pointing to guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction may stand even without an eyewitness to the actual killing when independent circumstances form one unbroken chain pointing to the accused as the perpetrators. For persons facing criminal charges, complainants […]

When One Credible Witness Can Defeat an Alibi in a Criminal Trial

A lone credible witness may sustain conviction despite alibi, denial, and lack of motive when identity is clearly established and testimony matches physical evidence. A conviction can stand on the testimony of a single witness when that testimony is positive, credible, and consistent with the physical evidence. For accused persons, victims’ families, and trial lawyers, […]

When a Confession Becomes Evidence: Why Conspiracy Can Defeat Alibi and Fear Defenses in Criminal Cases

The Court affirmed robbery with homicide, holding that voluntary confessions, coordinated acts, and weak alibi can prove conspiracy beyond reasonable doubt. People accused of a serious crime cannot defeat conviction by simply saying their confession was forced, that they were only afraid of a co-accused, or that they were somewhere nearby. The Petenia ruling reinforces […]

When Self-Defense Fails: Why an Accused Who Admits the Injury Must Prove Every Element

Self-defense failed where the accused admitted the injury but failed to prove unlawful aggression; attempted homicide was reduced to physical injuries. A person who admits wounding another cannot rely on self-defense by simply claiming fear, confusion, or pursuit; once self-defense is invoked, the burden shifts to the accused to prove unlawful aggression, reasonable necessity, and […]

When an Accomplice’s Story Is Enough to Convict: The Co-Conspirator Testimony Rule in Robbery with Homicide

A co-conspirator’s testimony may support conviction when sincere, detailed, and consistent with the evidence, as shown in a robbery with homicide ruling. A conviction may rest on an accomplice’s testimony when the account is sincere, direct, and detailed enough to show that it was not a calculated afterthought. For accused persons, complainants, and families involved […]

A Guilty Plea in a Capital Case Is Not Enough Without a Searching Judicial Inquiry

The Supreme Court set aside a death sentence because the trial court accepted a guilty plea without a searching inquiry and evidence on the charge. A person accused of the gravest crimes cannot be condemned on a bare plea of guilty unless the trial judge first makes sure, on the record, that the accused fully […]

A Confession Alone Is Not Enough, But Corroborated Evidence Can Still Convict

A confession can support conviction only when voluntary and corroborated by independent proof that the crime occurred, including medical and property evidence. A person may be convicted on the strength of an extrajudicial confession only when the prosecution proves that the confession was voluntary and that the crime itself was independently established by evidence outside […]

Oral Confessions, Alibi, and Conspiracy: Why Coordinated Acts Can Convict Even Without Written Admissions

Courts may convict based on credible oral confessions, eyewitness identification, and coordinated acts showing conspiracy, even without written admissions. Criminal liability may be proven through credible eyewitness testimony, oral confessions, and the coordinated acts of several accused, even when no written confession exists and even when each accused raises a separate alibi. For businesses, property […]

A Guilty Plea in a Capital Case Is Not Enough Without a Real Safeguard Against Mistake

A guilty plea in a capital case requires safeguards, but substantial compliance may sustain conviction while lack of required votes prevents death penalty. An accused who pleads guilty to a capital offense is not automatically beyond protection: the trial court must still make sure that the plea is informed, voluntary, and supported by a record […]

When a Confession Can Convict: The Supreme Court’s Rule on Voluntary Admissions and Re-Enactments

The Court held that a voluntary extrajudicial confession and re-enactment can sustain conviction despite later coercion claims and alibi. A criminal conviction may stand on an extrajudicial confession when the prosecution proves that the admission was made freely, voluntarily, and with sufficient safeguards against coercion. For accused persons, police investigators, and private complainants, the Caramonte […]