Tax Treaty Refunds Need Proof: Why Most-Favored-Nation Clauses Do Not Automatically Lower Royalty Withholding Tax

Most-favored-nation treaty relief for royalties requires proof of similar tax circumstances; Cargillโ€™s refund was denied for lack of evidence. A taxpayer claiming a lower treaty rate under a most-favored-nation clause must prove more than the existence of another Philippine tax treaty with a lower rate. It must show that the royalties are of the same […]

The Similar Circumstances Rule: Why a Lower Tax Treaty Rate Does Not Automatically Create a Refund

A lower treaty royalty rate cannot be borrowed automatically; taxpayers must prove similar circumstances before claiming a Philippine tax refund. A taxpayer claiming a lower treaty rate must prove more than the existence of a better rate in another Philippine tax treaty. Under the Similar Circumstances Rule, a most-favored-nation clause applies only when the foreign […]