COMELEC Plebiscite Deference: When Courts Will Uphold Election Results

COMELEC plebiscite results stand absent grave abuse; fraud claims require the proper remedy and convincing evidence. COMELEC plebiscite decisions will not be overturned merely because voters, local officials, or losing advocates allege confusion, irregularities, or disappointing turnout. Under the COMELEC Plebiscite Deference Doctrine, the Supreme Court will generally respect the Commission on Elections’ administration of […]

Local Tax Ordinance Appeals: When City Tax Hikes Exceed LGC Limits

Cities cannot impose accumulated local tax hikes beyond LGC limits; taxpayers must challenge illegal ordinances through the proper appeal route. Local governments cannot wait years, accumulate unused taxing power, and then impose a one-time business tax increase beyond the Local Government Code’s 10 percent adjustment ceiling. For retailers and other businesses facing new city revenue […]

Courts Cannot Hand Corporate Control to an Outsider by Injunction

Corporate control belongs to the board, not an outside intervenor. The Supreme Court stopped an injunction that handed management to a private claimant. Corporate control cannot be transferred by a trial court to a private outsider merely because that outsider has a contract with someone claiming authority over the corporation. Management of a stock corporation […]

CTA Certiorari Power: Where Local Tax Disputes Must Be Fought

Local tax certiorari petitions from RTC interlocutory orders belong in the CTA, not the Court of Appeals, avoiding split jurisdiction. Local tax disputes do not always belong in the Court of Appeals: when a Regional Trial Court issues an interlocutory order in a local tax case, the proper court to review that order by certiorari […]

Can a Litigant Be Ordered to Produce Income Tax Returns in a Civil Case?

A taxpayer claiming lost income may be ordered to produce ITRs; broad tax confidentiality claims and improper Rule 65 remedies will not stop trial evidence. A taxpayer who puts lost income at issue in a civil case may not automatically defeat a court order to produce personal income tax returns by invoking tax confidentiality. When […]

Photocopies Can Prove Corporate Misappropriation When the Originals Are Lost

Lost originals do not automatically defeat a case. The Supreme Court allowed photocopies after proof of loss, authenticity, and admissions by the accused. Corporate officers accused of keeping company funds cannot defeat a criminal case simply by objecting that the prosecution has only photocopies, if the originals were lost without bad faith and the prosecution […]