When Supervening Events End a Tax Recovery Fight: Why Courts Will Not Decide Discovery Disputes That No Longer Matter

The Supreme Court dismissed the Republic’s certiorari petition as moot after document inspection occurred and the recovery complaint was dismissed. Parties in tax recovery, forfeiture, and government asset cases cannot expect appellate courts to resolve procedural discovery fights after the underlying controversy has already been overtaken by later events. When the requested inspection has already […]

Bank Complaints Dismissed by BSP Can Be Refiled, Not Immediately Elevated to Certiorari

BSP complaints dismissed without prejudice for lack of prima facie evidence should generally be refiled with stronger proof, not elevated by certiorari. A dismissed BSP administrative complaint does not always end the dispute. When the Office of the Special Investigation dismisses a bank complaint for lack of a prima facie case, the complainant’s immediate remedy […]

Courts Should Not Defeat a Settlement Over Curable Formal Defects

A compromise agreement may bind parties despite curable formal defects when consent, authority, and legality are clear. Courts should favor valid settlements. A signed compromise agreement may bind litigants even when it contains imperfections in form, so long as the parties consented, their representatives were authorized, and the agreement is not contrary to law, morals, […]

Judges Are Not Liable for Delay When Due Process Requires Waiting

Delay by a judge is not misconduct when due process requires resolving ownership and hearing parties first; bad faith or malice must be shown. A judge’s delay in resolving a motion does not automatically amount to administrative misconduct when the delay is tied to a real need to hear all affected parties and settle a […]

A Missed Pre-Trial Brief Should Not Automatically Cost You the Case

A late pre-trial brief did not justify default where the parties appeared in court; certiorari was allowed because appeal was inadequate. Litigants who appear in court should not lose their entire case merely because a pre-trial brief was filed late, especially when the Rules penalize failure to appear at pre-trial—not failure to submit a brief […]

Certiorari Is Not a Shortcut When an Ordinary Appeal Is Available

Certiorari cannot replace an available appeal. Enriquez v. Rivera warns litigants that using the wrong remedy may doom even a serious procedural challenge. Certiorari is an extraordinary remedy, not a second route for a losing litigant who still has an ordinary appeal. For taxpayers, property owners, employers, and businesses challenging adverse court or agency orders, […]